There is a crying need to make public transport more affordable. Re-nationalisation of rail is one way to do this.

Jan Smith, Nelson

All the train companies employ an army of people whose sole purpose is to argue about the attribution of delays – not to improve performance, just to save money.

Phil Simpson

Public rail transport isn’t working. It’s no longer a reliable way of getting to where you need to be on time. In the north of Scotland people are returning to their cars.

Alan Roberts, Dingwall

I agree with all previous comments, and we need our train network to be re-nationalised as soon as possible.

Janet Guest, Sheffield

Bring back British Rail.

Jools Johnston-Elliott, Faversham

Currently we have the worst privatisation. The loss of British Rail started the robbery from the people to the powerful.

Ian Enters, Sheffield

British Rail was not perfect by any stretch of the imagination but it was better than what we tolerate now. ECML have shown what can be achieved. Now for the rest.

Peter Brown, London

Privatisation has not worked for our railways. Check out what comedian Mark Thomas has to say.

Dave Waugh, Edinburgh

I loved British Rail as a tourist. I miss it.

Nea McKeon, Albuquerque, USA

Severe lack of peak time trains (e.g. back/forth Brighton) and also lack of scheduling with local bus services, makes getting to work time-consuming, expensive and awful.

N Zaidi, Brighton

Bring back BR.

Alan Gowar, Brighton

British rail was the best and most reliable railway we ever had in this country. We need our railway back now!

Brandon Nicholls, Manchester

Ernie Marples was the Wallasey MP (Tory) was the man who gave Beeching the job of destroying the railway system many years ago. I’m glad to say that we no longer have him.

Douglas Holmes, Wallasey

They put the fares up year after year but as a taxpayer I am hit twice as I have to subsidise them as well.

Derek Ramsay, Chatham

How anyone could be so stupid as to privatise a successful, publicly owned company I cannot understand.

Tony And Marjory Elliott, Durham

Enough. Bring back a public travel service to the public.

Jillian Wood, London

The present system needs to change.

Susan Turner, York

The awful privatised railways are ours. Please give them back to us.

David White, Hull

I do not drive, I use public transport all the time. It most definitely should be run not-for-profit. It’s a service, not a money-grabbing opportunity, or at least it should be.

Philip Corbould, Rugby

As tax payers we pay more than any other country to run the rail network millions of us depend upon every day.

David Mcintosh

Brilliant initiative to try to Bring back British Rail. Good luck. It’s the best idea I have heard in years.

Beverley Clark, Hartlepool

The privatised railways are vastly expensive money-pumps from the public purse.

Robert Cockcroft, Ashford, Kent

BR was a nationwide co-ordinated rail system. BR needed much less government subsidy than the current fragmented privatised system. Bring back BR.

Tim Stevens, Peterborough

Privatisation hasn’t worked for the travelling public. Politicians, their friends, corporate bodies, the City etc. have profited from privatisation. It’s a public service.

Robert Harper, Nottingham

I hate the ‘cheap’ advance fare system that enables train operators to dodge the real issue of extortionate fares when questioned about rises. Fares should be per mile.

Jane Atchison, Bristol

I have not used the train more than 4 times since it was de-nationalised.

M Lovious, Liverpool

Privatisation has made rail services much worse. Trains are cattle trucks not for humans.

Judith Wade, Hemel Hempstead

British Rail. It says it in the name. British – and need I say more?

Jacqui Jones, Chertsey

So we gave it a go and it failed us all. Bring back British Rail.

Jamie Robertson, London

It’s time to stop the train operating companies running the rail network into the ground.

Daniel Collins, Brentwood