Selling vital services for profit is a short-sighted disgrace. Bringing back BR would reduce the complexity of our rail network and benefit national transportation.

John Halfpenny, Ripley

Privatisation has never made anything cheaper or more efficient despite spurious claims to the contrary at its inception, witness the debacle in energy, water etc.

Stuart Tomlin, Rugby

Railways, like the supply of water and power, should be seen as common goods, provided out of taxation and run for the benefit of all.

Keith Gray, Rothbury

British Rail should never have been privatised and Virgin can cover the East Coast line costs from its West Coast profits.

Barry Davies, Stafford

One of the worst things we did was sell off all the utilities and British Rail. It’s about time we brought them back as not-for-profit organisations.

Richard Cooley, Shipley

The free market ideology that privatised railways means profit for the few while the state bails out. It’s the same with the energy companies and now the NHS.

Garry Thomas, Strathaven

It should not be cheaper and more convenient for me to commute to work by car.

Elise Smith, Canterbury

It doesn’t have to be a re-run of BR. There are other ways of having a publicly funded rail system – see Germany for example.

Chris Barker, London

I want the labour Party to put this in the general election manifesto and then, when elected, do it!

Tony Jones, Reading

Business and railways don’t mix. As a natural monopoly, there is no real competition amongst providers to deliver a service of good value and high quality.

Matthew Shewbridge, London

The East Coast line makes a net profit run by the public sector. Perhaps the rest can too.

Jenny Shevlin, Leeds

Privatisation was never going to succeed. It failed as a privatised industry when first created and it will fail again.

Robert Bergh, Ipswich

Some rail fares are now just ridiculous and the profits being extracted by management companies should be kept by the people.

Mr. R. J. Aston, Thurgarton, Nottinghamshire

British rail should be British Rail.

Jennifer Andrew, Bicester

We must get back for the people what the British taxpayer laboured long and hard for.

Catherine Spink-White, Perth

Bring back British rail

Phillip Dunkirk, Harrogate

BBBR Now. Stop the waste of money going to shareholders and out of the railway industry.

Steven Parkes, Glasgow

Current TOCs are incompetent.

Peter Frampton, Manchester

Let’s get people moving on the trains at a good price. All working together. Unify our rail.

Mike Bond, Bristol

We want our railway back.

Raymond Crois La, Kampen

Privatisation is for the few to get stinking rich. The clue is in the word private.

John Doyle, Addlestone

I fully support this idea.

Paul Higgins, Halesowen

Profits should go into the railways, not the pockets of the rich.

Brian Matthews, Wrexham

Trains are public transport. It is obscene for a private company to run them for profit.

Mark Dawson, Carshalton

Put an end to greedy private companies fleecing passengers for profits.

Justin Griffiths, Gosfield

Stop privatising as it doesn’t work.

Michael Johnston, Northampton

Give it back.

Robert Taylor, Chorley

The only people who will benefit from this are the shareholders who will be fleecing the general public.

Tim Zacharia, Croydon

They should never have been privatised. Public transport should be a public service, for the benefit of the passengers, not for the subsidised profit of a few shareholders.

Ian Brown, Cheadle

The railways were invented here. We should be able to take pride in an excellent system that puts people first and is economical too.

Carol Newmarch, Middlesbrough