Privatisation has given us a very expensive and inefficient way of travelling. It never worked and never will.

Peter Dillon, Sheffield

As a socialist I believe in production for use not for profit. Economic and social benefits of re-nationalisation in many areas, not just the railways, are very appealing.

Dara Foody, Harrow

British rail should never have been privatised, especially for profit I say re-nationalise the service.

Carole Frost, Birtley

I sincerely hope this works.

Ann Bennett, Kings Langley

Keep ticket prices low.

C Prime, Newark

I’m outraged that huge public subsidies and high fares make massive profits for overseas based companies.

Adrian Ashwell, Brighton

The service provided by Chiltern is woefully inadequate. Clearly not enough resources are allocated to developing infrastructure.

Clare Simmonds, Beaconsfield

The success of the East Coast Line clearly demonstrates how much better the railways are in public ownership.

Caroline Pickering, Northallerton

Today the railway is purely driven to provide profit. Safety and improvement to the system are a secondary thought. Bring back BR.

Jonathan Stevenson

In a world where our “public” services just keep getting worse and worse, please see sense.

Christopher Fazey, Chester

Services continue to deteriorate whilst prices continue to rise and subsidies increase. Bring the rail companies back into public ownership and public service.

Julie Chow, Wallington

If British Rail had received the level of subsidy afforded to the private sector, none of the money would have gone to shareholders and the network would be better for it.

Matt Tyas, St Ives

BR fell apart when greedy politicians started meddling. It should be run with no political agenda providing a good service at a fair price and provide jobs for the UK.

Sue Crathorne, Birmingham

Rail is a natural monopoly and therefore all arguments in favour of marketisation are a complete nonsense.

Nick Shepley, Cardiff

When you watch the history of British Rail, the workers had such a pride in their jobs. Bring back British Rail. Less competition with apportioning blame.

Veronica Reilly, Livingston

I’d like to see the railways re-nationalised and run for the good and benefit of people, and not for private profit.

Matthew Jones, Telford

I currently work for Network Rail.

Karanjit Juss, Birmingham

UK railways are in a shocking state.

Mark Kapalo, Telford

Enough is enough.

Richard Jones, Plymouth

Why pay dividends to shareholders when the money would be better spent on renewing the rails and trains?

Ian Sadler, Leeds

It’s a great idea. The way it was privatised was absolutely crazy. The railway system should be efficient, punctual and user-friendly.

Reiko Hara, London

A publicly owned railway would be able to integrate services and be more answerable to passengers. It works in France and Italy.

Jennifer Carpenter, Sheffield

Bring back British Rail for the benefit of everyone, not just the shareholders.

John Coates, Birmingham

I’m an ex-BR permanent way worker, back in the days when we knew every inch of the track in our area.

Kevin McGrath, Great Yarmouth

I fully agree with bring back British Rail. It was the worst thing the government has ever done, like the rest of public utilities.

Male Byrne, Southampton

East Coast is putting money back into the public purse rather than into profits for shareholders. That is as it should be. Every privatisation raises prices.

Theresa Marsden, Peterborough

Improve the train service, and make it more affordable prices for workers.

Grace Keeley, London

The privatised railway system which was imposed upon us is manifestly not fit for purpose. It is fractured and massively expensive both to run and travel on.

Stephen Thomas, London

If it was in public ownership it would still need a lot of work to make it a decent service. It was not perfect.

Marie Phillips, Rotherham

Why do we have such an expensive and antiquated rail system ? Bring back British Rail.

Simon Blackmore, Manchester