I’d rather go by train than drive, but the sad fact is the car is far cheaper, even when proportionally factoring in initial price, tax, insurance, fuel and depreciation.

Pete Williams, Southampton

I am a frequent user of rail transport and can’t believe the overall poor quality for the cost of the service, compared to other countries.

Paul Morgans, Bakewell

My father, my granddad, my uncle, my ex-partner all worked on BR. How it has been run and maintained the past few years has been of great concern to me.

Sharon Roberts, Colchester

Bring it back and let’s do away with all the bureaucracy.

Christopher Wilson, Basingstoke

Why privatise something which is making a profit and doing the job well?

Brenda Topley, Leeds

Provide a cost-effective, reliable, public transport service which is not driven by profit for shareholders.

Andrew Wilson, Swindon

People deserve a safe, reliable rail service that is affordable.

John Farrar, Stoke-on-Trent

Re-nationalisation is free at the point of contract renewal, and overall the franchises can make a profit. Keep infrastructure safe from vulture capitalism.

David Roberts, York

Subsidies should go towards running the trains, not to train operating companies.

Jim Waight, Hertford

Since it’s been private it’s all about profit and not service.

Alan Johnson, Liverpool

We’ve seen privatisation exploit its passengers, now let’s see nationalisation serve its passengers.

Chris Knowles, Deal

People should be placed before profit. For that reason the railway industry is to be taken back to public ownership.

Kwasi Agyemang-Prempeh, London

If they can do it in the rest of Europe, why not here?

Trish Joscelyne, East Sussex

Critical infra-structure like railways should be owned by the public as in many European countries.

Barry Graham, York

It is time to stop this nonsense of private companies making profits from public subsidy and ripping off the travelling public.

Paul Andrews, London

Fares have gone up too much.

Daniel Codrington , Crawley

Why when it is making money for the downtrodden taxpayer do they want to turn it over to losers?

Helen Herridge, Conwy

Welcome back British Rail.

Maureen Brookman, Sutton, Surrey

And the power companies.

Marwan Mohammed, Hastings

They shouldn’t ever have been sold because they didn’t belong to the government of the day. Anything state-owned should be put to a referendum before selling.

Peter Stratten, Cardiff

The railway infrastructure and all other infrastructure should be owned by the state as, for example, in France.

Liz Yates, High Wycombe

Let those currently running the Great Northern line run the rest of the railways. They are doing a better job than the rest already.

Richard Painter, Waltham Cross

The rail companies monopolise the lines, charging whatever they want.

Julian Gore

Rip-off Britain must be stopped.

Clifford Tynan, Wantage

The poorest suffer; the richest grow richer.

Phil Wall, Pontypridd

Hands off our railway. It is making a good profit. Stop selling off the crown jewels.

Jennifer Ware, York

We can do better with our railways when they aren’t subsidising the railways of other countries.

John Airey, Peterborough

They put the fares up year after year but as a taxpayer I am hit twice as I have to subsidise them as well.

Derek Ramsay, Chatham

It works so why mess it up again.

Tony Tyler, Letchworth Garden City

I’m tired of being over-charged and exploited by my train company. I want fair fares and a service that runs on time – for everyone.

Hazel Willis, Saffron Walden