Yes, I believe it is time to re-open our rural rail links. It could prove profitable now as population has increased.

Nick Ridgway, Plymouth

East Coast sell off is a disgrace. We need more public ownership, not less ideologically driven profiteering.

Mick Barry, Brightlingsea

End rewarding shareholder profits for high price tickets and cost driven, unreliable services. Invest in the railways and get cars and trucks off the roads.

Sean Durney

Nationalised services are more accountable, therefore provide better service and are more cost-effective.

Rosie Butterworth, Orpington

Give the services back to the people. Everyone is happier when they are employed by a national rail service, or any other publicly owned service.

Stella Beston, London

Privatisation has not worked. The East Coast mainline is now back in public hands and is running really well, re-nationalise the rest.

Robert Measday, Swansea

End the railway rip-off, joke fare increases and disgracefully inept service of the franchises. We want a service like DB in Germany.

Alexander Culley, London

One ticket, one destination, one rail company. Simplicity. Bring back British Rail.

Julie Elphick, Witney

Transport for people and environment, not for profit.

Pat McCarthy, Cleveland

I’m president of Birmingham Trades Union Council. All public transport should be in public hands. People before profit.

Mary Pearson, Birmingham

Nationalise our railways. Any profit should benefit its users, not go into pockets of shareholders.

Christopher Gale, Nottingham

Bring back British Rail.

Richard Smith, Eastleigh

Rail privatisation has been a disaster except for a few company directors and other major shareholders.

Alan Campbell, Balerno

Everyone’s utterly fed up and disillusioned with this current system – it just doesn’t work.

Christine Hill, London

We need to have it back in government control as the companies are only thinking of profit for themselves and not the commuters.

Graham Lawrence, Dundee

Public transport should benefit the public, not a few shareholders.

Stephen Clibbens, Harrogate

Even with a 16-25 railcard I can barely afford to travel by train to work. There’s barely any point in my travelling to work with the amount I spend on train fares.

Vincent Barker, Northampton

We need all train companies and Network Rail nationalised.

Michael McDonald, Livingston

This is an essential service, and our tickets and subsidies should not be used to line CEOs pockets.

Amy Lisle, Nottingham

Railways should be run on a not-for-profit basis, just like the NHS. There are plenty of good managers who could make British Rail a much better service for us.

Paul Rossall, Newark

It would be great to get the rail fairs back to something reasonable in a way that makes sense. Chester to Liverpool

Susan Shaw, Chester

Let’s have it.

Ian Woodford, Ipswich

It’s a bloody liberty.

Joseph O’Sullivan, Ware

Anything would be better than the utter shambles that is Southern.

Neill Truett, St Leonard’s-on-Sea

Between some places in the UK it is cheaper to board a flight than catch a train. This is wrong.

Luke Smith

The current franchise agreements mean that profits can be sucked away from the railways by private companies, yet the government then has to stump up money for investment.

Peter Dickinson, Brierley Hill

The current situation is out of control. Let’s use the rail service as a tool for building a future for Britain.

Sean Kelly, Loughborough

Why did we ever privatise a fantastic national system? It doesn’t work.

Tim Pickles, Cardiff

The Green Party are fighting to bring the rail network back into public ownership.

Will Duckworth, Dudley

A necessity that is run for profit and greed, the same as the utilities.

Lucy Musk, Welwyn Garden City