British Rail should be for the people not for getting fat cats fatter,

Derrick Jones, Stockton-on-Tees

As a regular traveller I care passionately about rail travel. Under unified, coherent, public management/ownership it would be so much better.

Penny Wilcox, Exeter

Privatisation hasn’t worked for many franchisees and definitely hasn’t worked for the passenger. Bring back BR. DB was 100% cheap and punctual when I worked in Germany.

Colin Wane, Barnsley

Actually, the railways secretly remained nationalised, in the sense that the government pays for them. But they makes us think they’re private, because they don’t run them anymore.

Nigel Miller, Wallington

Britain saw the birth of railways, but since privatisation the system has steadily declined and fallen well behind other countries. It’s in the public interest to improve.

Chris Poulton, London

Don’t waste money on HS2. Just get us an affordable transport system.

Steve Mulvale, Padstow

Bring back BR.

George Osborne, Wells

The UK needs a public unified rail service for public transport.

Jon Rust, Holmfirth

Investment in the service and for those who use it can’t by wasted in dividends.

Jill Sanders, Hampton

Fares are too expensive under private control. Improve the service by investing money into the network directly and not into scandalous salaries and bonuses.

Pedro Pereira, Milton Keynes

Not only Bring back British Rail, but bring back the branch lines as well.

Gabrielle Seymour, London

This proud institution should never have been dismantled in the first place. Like so many other services, they place profit before people…

Sally Freear, Heysham

Our fragmented railways are in a mess – expensive and unreliable. We need a nationalised service where all revenue goes back into the service and not shareholders’ pockets.

Barbara Segal, Bristol

We want our trains powered by glorious Rolls Royce engines and new modernised Class 42s to be introduced.

Clare Wood, Inverness

To be serious about green issues we need cheap, frequent and reliable public transport, i.e. re-nationalised.

Rachel Mulliner, Stockport

Why on earth did we ever privatise the rail network? We have the only private network in Europe and it’s the worst run. Stop emulating America. BBBR!

Dale Barnard, Glasgow

I believe that British Rail should never have been privatised. Britain should be British and proud of it, so let’s make it publicly-owned and British again.

Alison Richards, Penzance

If the private sector wants it, it’s because it makes them money, and know the government will bail them out if it loses. The state should make the profit if it takes the risk.

Lorraine Winson, Chesterfield

Privatisation is the result of lazy governments absolving themselves of their responsibilities. British Rail simply suffered from lack of investment by such governments.

Alan Varty, Durham

I well remember when it was possible to buy a ticket at almost any station to travel to almost any other station in the UK. This, of course, was with British Railways.

Kenneth Sherrocks, Liverpool

I travel every day using Southern. They have been making my travel a misery for the last year and it’s getting worse by the day. It’s outrageous what they make people go through.

Martin Siedek, London

I hardly ever travel by train as it’s too expensive. When I do there have been all manner of delays and breakdowns and filthy toilets.

Carol Tanner, Penzance

Track, rolling stock, time-tabling, maintenance planning, financing all run by one organisation working for the same purpose. What’s wrong with the common sense of that?

Roger Gowers, Telford

For the people, not private profit.

Eirin Julie Ingebrigtsvoll, London

The railways are abysmal. If the railways were run for a good service and not profit more people would use them. And we’d help the environment.

Tom McGiveron, Lower Peover

The nation’s industries – working with vision.

Robert Davidson, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Ticket prices keep rising but services are no better. Where’s the benefit for those of us paying for the service?

Kaitlin Milford

I totally agree. Southern Rail have an appalling service this summer, and it’s only getting worse. These rail companies have run out of excuses.

Michael Ludlam, Coulsdon

It seems that it is OK for a government enterprise to own our railway, so long as it is German or French.

Tim Evans, Camborne