Yes – bring some professionalism back to running the railway.

Mike Peart, Sheffield

It’s time to put efficiency, cost effectiveness and punctuality ahead of corporations’ profits. Nationalisation isn’t socialist rubbish, it’s in the nation’s interests.

Jamie Wilson, Camberley

Keep British Rail ours.

Margaret Havercroft, Harrogate

Bring back BR.

Daniel Brown, Leiston

Affordable transport is essential. Prices currently out of reach.

Linda Phillips, Croydon

Bring it back but no more excuses like wrong kind of leaves on the track.

Tim Hardy, Portsmouth

Bus companies owning the railways for clear conflict of interest/cartel/profit. What could possibly go wrong?

Mike Sollitt, York

Bring back British Rail and get rid of all the TOCs and bring it under one umbrella.

John Lowe, Oxford

British is best.

Ann Barnes, York

Overpriced fares, overcrowded and late trains. When FCC franchise runs out in 2014 the route should be taken back into public ownership. Put passengers before profits.

Teresa Smith, Royston

It just makes sense to me – people before profit. That goes for all the other utilities (gas/electricity/water) that have been privatised for the rich to make more money.

Lesley Jones, Hull

Essential services should be run by the public for the public. Profits and subsidies should be ploughed back in and not go into the pockets of private investors.

David James, Leeds

Where’s the competition when I can’t get a National Express train in Surrey?

Tony Rawlings, Woking

Why have we given it all away to foreign companies?

James Connor, Cumbernauld

Profits from the railways should be going to the Treasury, not to shareholders. East Coast has put millions into the Treasury and should be allowed to continue.

Elizabeth Sheard, Wolverhampton

Rail Prices are too high and the service is not worth it. People could move around easier under British Rail.

Barry Scott, Romford

If privatisation is so successful why do they rely on subsidies to keep their shareholders happy?

John Main, London

I was a teacher for 42 years in the public sector. The Conservatives want to privatise education and the NHS, and I think both would be disastrous, just like the railways.

Ted Goodhew, Maidenhead

Privately owned railways will never operate a rational fares structure. Irrational structures make them more profit.

Jago Tremain, Norwich

Transport, health and utilities should never be in the hands of the private sector.

James Siddle, Wakefield

Yes, a train service should be run for the benefit of all, not for the benefit for the few, heavily supported by public funds anyway.

Ken Oatlley, Corsham

The franchise model is totally unsuitable for a modern rail network. It is less efficient and we are being priced out of travel and sometimes our jobs.

Catherine Russell, Battle

East Coast Rail have shown that publicly-owned is better than privately-owned, for customers and taxpayers.

Stephen Helm, Ponteland

They need to lower the fares.

Waqas Sheikh, Leicester

Some things are too socially important to be run for private profit.

Kevin Bache, Bristol

Public transport should be run as a public service, not for private profit.

Roy Manterfield, Nottingham

A unified railway, with a much simplified fares structure, would be the best thing that could happen to this country.

Chris Martin, Worcestershire

East Coast have shown the way.

Peter Hepplewhite, Whitley Bay

While you’re at it, re-nationalise gas, electricity, phones and water.

Roddy Macdonald, Sheffield