I would like the profits to go into improving one national rail network, not into the pockets of disparate individuals each owning a bit of a fractured system.

Emma Hewitt, Pontefract

it is time to take our core industries away from the thieves and fat cats and restore them to the public sector. People before profits. Off with their heads.

Dean Bell, Retford

It is clear from the experience on the East Coast Line that nationalisation works.

David Penney, Colne

Oh the irony. Britain invented railways but we can no longer run them efficiently and cost-effectively.

Amanda Nicoll, Tadcaster

Stop shareholder profits.

Oliver Steward, Norwich

Please re-nationalise the railways in a modern and efficient way. We are a small island and are clogging up our roads. We need subsidised rail for everyone’s benefit.

Diane Bowe, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Anyone who has travelled on European trains knows that Britain has a rubbish rail system – slow, expensive, cramped and no longer fit to carry enough freight.

Denise Robson, Gateshead

We need a unified co-ordinated rail system.

Raymond Sansum, Milton Keynes

I travel regularly by train as I don’t drive. In the past 20 years it has become a disgusting experience. Drunks (therefore unsafe), filthy toilets, often no seats. It’s hell.

Morna Burdon, Edinburgh

I wholeheartedly support your campaign to re-nationalise the UK rail network.

Geoffrey Allen, Cramlington

Current arrangements are inefficient and over-complicated. There are better ways to spend government subsidy.

Andrew Webb, London

Overpriced, late, with intimidating staff at ScotRail. One bad apple rots the whole cart.

Louise Devlin, Glasgow

Privatisation means profit to shareholders. Pay them off and go back to good old British Rail.

Mr Tall, Louth

Railways are good for the environment. We need an efficient, affordable service to get people out of their cars and onto the trains.

K Thomas, Edinburgh

This situation is disgusting with no respect and no dignity.

George Moore, Ardrossan

In the 1980s British Rail had about 5 managers on high CEO salaries. The private railways now have 150.

Jacob Rothman, Llandrindod Wells

We pay more money per capita for our dreadful, privatised railway service than our European cousins, who enjoy an efficient, value-for-money, nationalised service.

Gemma Hill

Rail, and other essential services, need to be run for public benefit not for private profit.

Dave Miles, Nottingham

In a truly civilized, wise society, things like railways and our electricity/gas provision, should be run by the people for the people.

John Rochford, Middlewich

Privatisation is not working and we have the ridiculous situation whereby it is cheaper to run a car (with one occupant) than it is to make a rail journey.

Rebecca Gracey, Lewes

The current franchise agreements mean that profits can be sucked away from the railways by private companies, yet the government then has to stump up money for investment.

Peter Dickinson, Brierley Hill

Absolute shambles. I support anything that’ll make my commute safer.

Louise Allison, Falkirk

Try getting a seat out of Peterborough.

David Stock, Peterborough

Please re-nationalise our railways, as the privatisation of them is not working. We do not have to make a profit as it all goes into the pockets of the wealthy shareholders.

Vanessa Rambridge, Preston

Not even Thatcher was crazy enough to privatise the railways.

Stella Hawkins, Hounslow

Re-nationalisation of railways is easier than other privatised industries because at expiration existing franchises can be transferred to Directly Operated Railways.

Paul Reddy, Wirral

Put Michael Portillo in charge of British Rail. He must be independent of any political party, like the Queen.

Roz Lucas, Penryn

Public transport should not be run for private profit.

Lee Osborne, Skipton

The subsidies to the privatised companies are going into shareholders’ pockets. We need a properly integrated service. Only BR can do this.

B J Gibbons, Southampton