The current franchise agreements mean that profits can be sucked away from the railways by private companies, yet the government then has to stump up money for investment.

Peter Dickinson, Brierley Hill

Every day I get ripped off travelling to London for work (to pay taxes) yet I can’t afford to spend to fuel the economy, because the train company takes it all!

Sam Giles, Birmingham

The abolition of common sense is their (ATOC’s) worst crime. Bring back British Rail now.

David Jones, Bristol

I’m with you.

Edwin Robinson, Doncaster

Privatisation was done on the cheap, supposedly to allow the firms to upgrade the network which they reneged on.

Mark Stewart, Ayr

It is about time we re-nationalised railway system. It has been privatised for far too long!

Ben Walsh

Put it back where it belongs and that’s in the public hands not private.

Robert Edge, Ashford

You know it makes sense.

Andy Mizzi, Morecambe

All the millions hived off as corporate profit and dividend could have replaced the 40 year old trains suffered by commuters in the North West of England.

Alan Gibson, Stockport

It would be great to also see improvements to rolling stock used on regional services like here on the Carlisle to Newcastle line.

Mike Domingue, Hexham

It should be a public service not a gravy train.

Helene Hart, Camberley

I would love a re-unified national network run for people not profit.

Elizabeth Clark, Beccles

We need to remove road traffic and the return to rail is not helped by greedy private ownership. We must have a re-unified rail network. This is not rocket science.

Debbie Stephenson, Southport

Down with our corporate overlords.

Joseph Kemp, Keighley

We were told that privatisation would bring consumer choice and price competition. It hasn’t. It’s more expensive and grossly inefficient. Only large corporations benefit.

Fiona Kearns, Wakefield

The railways were much better in BR days. Now it’s just a confusing mess with all these train operators who are only interested in their own profits. Bring back BR.

Darren Kidd, Salisbury

It’s another thing that should never have been sold in the first place.

Adrienne Grimes, Leeds

The TOCs are inherently dysfunctional – they operate local monopolies with no incentive to improve services, and have no interest in saying a word against Network Rail.

John Paylor, London

The current state of affairs is ridiculous!

Kevin Reynolds, Brighton

Enough of the insanity.

Colin Raven, Manchester

Our rail fares are the highest in Europe.

Barbara Penny, Harrogate

Let’s keep on this. It’s so relevant and the trains are so expensive compared to Europe.

Barbara Ann Spencer, London

When train fares are catching up with rent something is wrong. Travelling cheaply and fairly would encourage people to commute to work and reduce unemployment.

Jim Ker, Leeds

Re-nationalise British Rail and the NHS, Post Office and do not privatise the probation service.

Helen Thompson, London

Of the many British institutions gradually being eroded by private ownership, an affordable and integrated rail system benefits us personally and environmentally.

Linda Combi, York

Needs to be done sooner rather than later. Most expensive public transport in Europe.

Philip Kane, London

About time, the profiteering rather than service idea makes me sick as a previous employee, now retired.

Michael Moloney, Banff

I was born in the same year as British Rail (1948) and I want it back.

Peter Collins, Stanley, Co. Durham

I hate the privatisation of public services.

William Holyday, London