I was a railwayman 1952 to 1993 and know that, with good management, a nationalised rail network can succeed.

David Bolton, Clacton on Sea

All service companies should never have been privatised.

Kate Rowland, Tywyn

Why are British train companies so bad?

Hannah Harrison, Manchester

The rail network should be government-owned, to resume order and assurance of safe, easy and improved travel infrastructure.

Vivek Katyara, Birmingham

The railway system is a service and a natural monopoly, not an ordinary business venture. It can be run efficiently and safely within the public sector. Time to do it.

Jim Steele, Ilkeston

Bring back BR!

Stephen Fay, Cwmbran

I am sick of being held to ransom by rip-off companies who put up prices and don’t pay proper taxes. Bring back British Rail and give us a service that is ours.

Mary Adams, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

The Great Train Robbery – the British privatised rail network.

Katie Goodwin, Tadley

They put the fares up year after year but as a taxpayer I am hit twice as I have to subsidise them as well.

Derek Ramsay, Chatham

Because I believe the basics in modern life should be state-owned and run for the good of the people, not profit for the rich.

Thomas Ingall, Bury St Edmunds

I would like to see BR brought back into service. All the current train liveries have confused me.

Damian Gevaux, Buckley

Keep it simple. One railway operator and save all the billing charges and lawyers’ costs.

Judith Hodgson, Liverpool

Privatisation is for the greedy rich, not the passengers.

Peter Sharples, Bolton

How is my station in Zone 4 while the one about half a mile from it – faster into London – is in Zone 6?

John Gilbert, Bromley

We were passengers, then we were customers, now we are parasites. Nationalisation is progress.

Ben Millis, London

The last 20 years have been a shambles, not least the Railtrack saga. Service standards on trains have also plummeted, whilst prices have rocketed.

Fraser Paterson, Edinburgh

Let the public sector manage our infrastructure for the benefit of our society and not the pockets of big business.

Simon Murray, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

We pay our fares to get somewhere, not to fill directors’ and shareholders’ pockets. Because of high wages and dividends there is no money for improvement works.

Malcolm Judd, Romford

Win votes by doing something for the people.

Lynn Lansbury, Sandown

A terrible idea to privatise in the first place. Please re-nationalise for the sake of the British people.

Christian Chess, Chippenham

We must get people to join together for this extremely worthy cause.

Malcolm Clayton

Rail reform is economic reform for the UK.

Lauren Godfrey, Brighton

I am fed up with stupid pricing and restrictive tickets, which just line the pockets of transport conglomerates like Arriva.

John Hurley, Gloucestershire

Privatisation is a crime.

Barry Brodbin, Broadstairs

I would like to bring back British Rail, as it will then be affordable for all and be a massive tourism boost. We would have a decent rail system like other countries.

Sarah Shahid, Sheffield

Trying to buy a railcard and finding out how restrictive tickets trains and times are is like swimming in treacle and I still have not succeeded several hours later.

S Blickem, Cambridge

The East Coast line shows how it should be done.

David Graham, West Yorkshire

As well as bringing back British Rail, we need the employees to have a bigger voice in the management of it.

Mat Fleming

I have been using the East Coast railway for 30 years. It has worked so efficiently in the last 5 years that I would hate it to be re-privatised.

Helen Main, Edinburgh

I’m a Tory supporter and backer of privatisations but I never supported privatising the railways which is chaotic. A centrally planned rail service is vital for the UK.

Ian Evans, Ipswich