For-profit ownership of the rail service simply doesn’t work. In most rural areas there is zero competition, so zero incentive for improvements or price reductions.

Joseph Burnham, Sheringham

Railways should be the best form of public transport. They should be efficient, reasonably priced and a public service, not a commercial carcase for stripping.

Charlotte Reader, Clacton-on-Sea

Now would be a good time to re-nationalise British Rail.

Jeremy Tothill, Oldbury

I have always loved travelling by train, as, when I was a child, my father was a guard.

Angela Lloyd, Newport

I was there. On April 1st, All Fools’ Day, when it was shambolically moved over.

Bernard Bannister, Peterborough

Re-nationalise the railways.

David Buckle, Cornhill-on-Tweed

Over the decades, privatised rail services have required a level of public subsidy far in excess of publicly-owned rail services, with little benefit to us.

Alex Lawson, Nottingham

Privatisation was the worst thing that happened to the railways. We are pouring money into private companies’ pockets.

Sandra Jervis, Wakefield

Privatisation is a farce. Fares are too expensive and with deranged, overcrowded, inadequate rolling stock and no integration. Bring Back BR.

Thomas Freeman, Halesowen

Privatisation brings too many fat cast and fewer jobs.

David McCormack, Hinckley

Please re-nationalise the railways in a modern and efficient way. We are a small island and are clogging up our roads. We need subsidised rail for everyone’s benefit.

Diane Bowe, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Why is it cheaper to travel by car than by train?

Philip Quinton, Aylesbury

Why is the railway punished so much? It’s starved of funding, sold off cheaply and then selfishness bleeds the profits.

Pete Thompson, Blackpool

British Rail is best!

Paul Thacker, Newport

It should never have been privatised in the first place.

John Collins, Lewes

Terrible service, abysmally stupid staff, under-trained over-paid lackeys.

Owen Smith, London

Transport infrastructure should belong to the public.

Paul Bright, Rotherham

My train fare goes up in price every year, and only to see millions of pounds spent on new stations, which result in even further delays and disruptions.

Bethan Williams, Caerphilly

Profit before service has gone on for too long.

Chris Williams, Bromley

British Rail should never have been sold off in the first place. It’s been an unmitigated disaster.

Andrea Charles, Port Talbot

Return to public ownership now to stop subsidising European railways.

Brenda Peacock, Shipley

We the people would very much like to see the railways re-nationalised. More focus on good service and profit being put into improvements rather than shareholders’ pockets

Davis Wilkie, Edinburgh

Privatisation did nothing but put shareholders first and customers last. It always has done and always will do.

N J T Lauro, Wirral

Rail travel is an essential part of daily life for lots of us and I believe that this service should be nationalised and focus on service not profit.

Michelle Bates, Leeds

Since train companies can’t compete and have a monopoly of their route, privatisation is a complete farce.

Alasdair Lumsden, London

Railways are a service, not for profiting shareholders with taxpayers’ money.

Colin Gill, Cambridge

It can be the only solution not to see the profits line the pockets of huge corporations. It’s embarrassing at the moment.

Arran Stratton, Glasgow

Privatisation does not bring automatic success. Look at G4, for example. It usually means increased prices and poorer service.

Betty Eade, Leeds

Privatisation has produced a worsening service.

Jennifer Hobson, Lapford

They should never have been privatised in the first place.

Giovanna Vettese, London