I’m old enough to remember when using the railways wasn’t a stressful task. There may have been some timing issues, but buying a ticket was so simple back then.

Jenny Gilbert, Wellington

The British Railways Board ran an excellent train service. These private companies are useless, typical Tory crap. So bring back British Rail.

Colin Flowerday, Holt

Re-nationalise the railways and make them better. There are too many top bosses getting crazy pay and bonuses which should be used to improve the network.

Steve Adie, Carlisle

I believe that without the involvement of private companies the railways would have little investment. I do believe in a national passenger operator (but just that).

Bertie Shaw, Deal

It’s long overdue. It’s time to admit mistakes. The French and Germans both have national rail systems as well as buying bits of ours.

Edmund Preston, Kinder

I wouldn’t want to bring back BR, but state ownership on the European model would be more than acceptable. East Coast trains show it can be done.

Amanda Blicq, Nottingham

We need a simple, affordable ticketing structure coupled with all the trains, tracks and stations being run by one publicly accountable body. That’s simple.

Nick Adams, Birmingham

Privatisation has made the railways much worse.

Ralph Baker, Margate

All public transport should be counted as a utility and all utilities should be re-nationalised.

Frank Evans, Chesterfield

Re-nationalise now.

Eva Schovneld, Edinburgh

Railways should be a social service, not a money making one. Profit making has benefit in some limited situations. It is not a one-size-fits-all miracle cure.

Roger Sternad, Doncaster

It’s about time we faced facts and realised that there will never be proper investment in rail under private ownership.

Damon Reid, Manchester

Ludicrously overpriced, unreliable. The rail system is awful.

Michael Kelland, London

The whole rail system is a mess. Bring back British Rail.

Peter Worth, Nottingham

I’m a regular commuter who loves public transport and I disagree that the profit motive is conducive to a better service.

Tom Coates, Huddersfield

I sincerely hope this works.

Ann Bennett, Kings Langley

As a retired British Rail Civil Engineer I will confirm that, with a direct labour workforce of BR employees right up to Chief Civil Engineers, we rocked.

Alan North, Spalding

The East Coast Line shows how successful public ownership can be, ploughing profits back into the Treasury. Privatisation is a failed ideology.

Robert Street, Dronfield

Re-nationalise the rail. Make it so it can stand on a par with Europe. Cheap and efficient.

Catherine Lowe, Bedford

Rail is a natural monopoly and should be run as a true service for the people, never for profit.

David Thompson, Liverpool

For the taxpayer not the shareholder.

Karl Madert, London

Privatisation has made the country poorer. Only big businesses like Virgin are gaining.

David Cross, Hull

Over-priced horrible trains ran for fat cats and not for the public good.

Patrick English, Sheffield

I am very happy to back this. Having travelled on German and Austrian trains this autumn, I am aware of the shortcomings in the British system.

Patricia Macnair, Glasgow

Not much chance of success considering the stance of HS2 and other moves to silence any protest.

Patricia Gwynnette, Rotherham

Please return to providing a safe and affordable service for people.

Liz Stewart, Witham

Private sector vultures have destroyed the railways. We will take them back by force if necessary.

Barry O’Toole, Liverpool

Stop this shambles of ever-increasing fares.

Frederick Toates, Milton Keynes

A nationalised UK company for all UK nations for the benefit of all.

Steven Paxton, Glasgow

We can do better with our railways when they aren’t subsidising the railways of other countries.

John Airey, Peterborough