If private enterprise can/will not run Railtrack/Network Rail, why should it operate the profit-making parts and hold fare-payers to ransom for an essential service?

Richard Gillanders, London

I am of the generation that remembers British Rail. It was not perfect, but during the Conservative years it was led by politicians who severely starved it of investment.

Patrick Hulme, Avon

If they’re charging fares like that, how much are they really making?

Brian Atkins, Cannock

What more to say? The current system is ridiculous.

Fahmid Chowdhury

I agree that we the people need to take it back from private ownership.

Chris Crossley, Sheffield

All profits should be ploughed back into the railway, not people’s pockets.

Louise Bishop, York

This lot would sell their own grannies.

Jayne Turner, Cardigan

Power to the people.

Brett Langsdale, Nottingham

A system for the people not for profit is needed.

Alan Lovegrove, Bracknell

Bring the railways back under state control and provide a better service to passengers.

Ian Roberts, Telford

A fragmented system is not a system. The whole thing is too complex to be efficient, effective and economical.

Roger Stokes, Bedford

Rail should be publicly-owned – and water.

Richard Fraser-Tait, Ryde

Nationalise… the sooner the better. We frequently holiday by rail in France. The service only ever falls apart when we arrive back in Britain.

William Marshall, Argyll

SWT is an absolute disgrace, they have made my life miserable for years whilst charging me hundreds of pounds a month. Constant delays, slow service, regular cancellations.

David Mendonca, London

When they brought in the new Railways why have it all split up with one company owning the tracks and another the stations etc. Bring it back under public ownership.

David Humphreys, Wrexham

Trains are public transport. It is obscene for a private company to run them for profit.

Mark Dawson, Carshalton

Since privatisation it’s gone from bad to worse – too much money – total rip-off. It was much better when it was good old British Rail

James Murphy, Cambridge

I completely agree.

Nicholas Seivewright, Dartford

Privatisation is a misuse of public assets. The assets were never yours to sell.

N. Holmes, Durham

It is a public service that should be in public hands.

Graham Garside, Southampton

Profits for the people.

Trevor Neat, Kenilworth

It’s a terribly disjointed and unsatisfactory national rail system, geared not towards public satisfaction but to private profit.

Luke Whaley

Bring back British Rail into public ownership. It’s a disgusting rip-off in privatised hands.

Annie Weatherly-Barton, Spalding

An innovative transport system built with the shovels, barrows and early graves of our Victorian forefathers – today’s capitalist corporation is an insult to their memory.

Peter Hannifan, Bournemouth

We simply must fight for a better life.

Stuart Flude, Durham

I totally agree with this. Get rid of the shambles that is the present system. I’m a steam enthusiast and would love to see some real British heritage brought back.

Matt Egerton, Manchester

Let’s see a return for trains being run as a customer service and not for private profit.

Nick Crago, Harlington

It makes no sense to fragment the railways. It’s been tried by John Major and the experiment failed miserably.

Robert Thomas, Northolt

Public transport should be public infrastructure not for profit.

Daniel Bell, Saltash

Privatisation hasn’t worked for the customer. Let’s have a joined up rail service that works for the customer. Competition hasn’t improved anything.

Gillian Trainor, Norwich