A good idea. East Coast main line has been better in public ownership.

Roger Kojan, Leeds

East Coast is better now than it has been for years.

Timothy Wilson, Dundee

BR was sold for Tory profit. Taxpayers were robbed of their investment. It’s time to take it back.

Mike Fowler, Peterborough

Amber Rudd is trying to kill our local rail route to implement another even more corrupt, private, expensive disservice in order to kill our town.

Em Law, Hastings

Stop profits being siphoned off into private pockets. Nationalise now.

Elmer Terry, London

I’m speechless with anger.

Ian Greenhalgh, Edinburgh

I remember the days before privatisation. The service was definitely cheaper and, for a customer, easier to use and understand.

Ruth Rolfe, Ely

Wasted money on private franchises – not good value for the general public.

Sandra Hanna, Selby

I just cannot stand the sub-standard service of First Great Western any longer, not whilst they’re being subsidised by the taxpayer but being run for profit.

Adam Sardar, Oxford

it was the worst thing this country did, getting rid of British Rail.

Wayne Parr, Wigan

Privatisation of the railways has proved to be a failure. Re-nationalise now.

Patrick Oakes, Baildon

Dealing with all the different rail companies is hopelessly confusing.

David Henderson, York

It makes eminent sense to have a national transport system run for the benefit of the country and not for private profit.

Tony Copeland, Boroughbridge

British Rail was privatised because it was said that British tax-payers should not subsidise the railways. We are now subsidising the privately owned companies far more.

Martha Young, Oxford

The rationale for selling off a national asset – that “competition” would lead to better services and lower prices – has proved to be faulty. Give it back.

Shellie Eyre, Nottingham

Although, fortunately, I no longer have to use the rail service as much as I had to before retirement, I find that the difference in pricing and such like is a minefield.

Douglas Searle, Rotherham

Let’s have a rail system where customer service not profit is the prime motivating force.

John Seymour, Sheffield

British Rail was for customers not for shareholders.

Patricia Spence, Reading

We lost a chunk of Britain when the small railway lines and stations were closed, and then some more when what was left was privatised. Put it all back where it belongs.

Chrissie Keelan, Preston,

We were promised that privatisation would reduce cost and improve services due to competition but the exact opposite has happened.

Angharad Bethan Davies, Bristol

Labour force mobility enriches the economy, and depends on affordable transport. The railway re-nationalisation process, which is already under way, needs completing now.

David Holt, Manchester

Down with Southern.

Ethan Storey, Chichester

Public services are not for profit.

Mark Donoghue, Dartford

Bring back British Rail. The system we have now is a farce.

Conor Healy, London

Re-nationalise the current rail system.

Jonathan Goode, Caterham

The current system is too complicated and unaccountable and civil servants would be too involved in micro-management. Let the railway be run by professionals again.

Patrick Adams, Barnstaple

East Coast has worked fine under public ownership recently. Why change it?

Stuart Jones, Lincoln

Privatisation isn’t working.

Annek Bulmer, Stockton-on-Tees

Take shareholders out of the equation and run rail as a service, not for private profit.

Fred Whitby, London

BR was better – not perfect, but better..

Nikki Doyle, Nottingham