The only way forward for our railways is in the public sector as a non profit company. No greedy shareholders and over-paid directors to cream off the profits.

Robin Lenox, Whippingham, Isle of Wight

Stop the fat cats getting richer and still costing the taxpayer a fortune in subsidies.

Brian Cane, Uttoxeter

The idea of running a key transport service for profit with no real competition has seen prices rise and no improvement in service. This is pricing out many people.

Connor Gray, Fareham

East Coast livery dull. Bring back GNER livery.

Alasdair Burman, Skipton

For environmental reasons rail travel needs to be efficient and cheap.

Caroline Barenghi, Ponteland

The railway needs to operates as a unified mass transit system with adequate trains, staff and reasonable fares. I’m fed up with being ripped off by fat cats.

Mark Matthews, Northampton

Private train companies are making an average return of 147% on every pound they put into their business, while fares are rising and I can’t afford to travel anymore.

Stephen Wright, London

Southern Rail made my life misery for years and may now prevent me from moving from London back to Brighton to be closer to my family, as I might not be able to get to work.

Claudia Tarry, London

Making vast profits on public transport is obscene.

Diane Allman, Wiltshire

As well as bringing back British Rail, we need the employees to have a bigger voice in the management of it.

Mat Fleming

Please fix the broken and disjointed rail mess that has stemmed from the privatisation in the 90’s.

James Delaney, Brighton

Please re-nationalise our railway lines.

Dave Devaney, Liverpool

Bring back British Rail, please.

Samuel Joshua, London

British Rail should never have been privatised in the first place.

Jane Morris, Bedford

All British utilities should be publicly-owned, not just British Rail, but all public transport and water, electricity and gas, and all should be run as not-for-profit.

Douglas Carey, Epsom

I believe that it is very important to have a unified, not-for-profit railway sytem to provide travel at reasonable cost..

Derek Bibb, Glasgow

Public service should not be in private hands.

Dick Norton, Cupar

Abso-bloomin-lutely.

Cathy Teesdale, London

People before profit means Bring back British Rail.

Eithne Bennett, York

And when we have re-nationalised the railways, next will be energy and power.

Dennis Hunter, London

I totally agree with your proposal – nothing else to say – we all know it makes sense.

Ralph Holden, London

The current set-up is not sustainable. Only a country can run its infrastructure – and a country wouldn’t spend billions on the old technology of HS2.

Andrew Hall, York

The privatisation experiment has failed. Rail transport is an integrated service essential to the economy and needs public ownership.

Tessa Gordziejko, Hebden Bridge

BR wasn’t perfect but it did usually have sufficient carriages to fulfil a generally decent service. The TOCs claim rail growth is due to their efforts. It’s not.

Alan Brown, Hull

If only British Rail had got the subsidies all these private railway companies receive, what a network we could have had.

William Paddock, Edinburgh

I totally agree with bringing British Rail back. Instead of rail being in corporate hands, give it back to the people.

Mark Pullen, Ripley

Privatisation hasn’t worked. Re-nationalise now.

Sue Millman, London

Outrageous is the lack of a national rail service in this country. It was better when we had one.

Daisy Green, Bideford

East Coast has performed efficiently and profitably since being temporarily back with us. It’s time for a full re-nationalisation.

Michael Clarke, Plymouth

Bring back British Rail to give the customers a better deal.

Martin Dawson, Edinburgh