It’s blindingly obvious that if you have several dozen private companies running all parts of the rail system, a large chunk of income will be lost.

Gerald Milward-Oliver, Bradford-on-Avon

This is a complex infrastructure which needs holistic management.

Tim Lewes Gibbon, London

Bring back British Rail.

Paul English, Eastbourne

If only Miliband had some guts and re-nationalised the whole shebang of former public industries.

David Abbott, France

Rail privatisation was a hurried, botched disaster. Costly for the UK taxpayer and has brought no real long-lasting benefit. Bring it back under our control..

Richard Edwards, Cirencester

Let’s have more railway stations in places that are now removed from the rail network, yet are major market towns. Reverse Beeching.

Mary Humphreys, Ely

We own it. We want it back, now.

E Gude, Huddersfield

The country needs an efficient integrated railway system to facilitate economic growth.

Brian Alston, Maidstone

It’s time for change. Re-nationalisation is the only way.

Jonathan Edwards, Stroud

A privatised railway is bound to put profits before passengers and often safety is compromised for the sake of profits as well.

David Jackson, Nottingham

Privatisation of the rail service has been a disaster: overcrowded, unreliable, expensive. End this folly now.

Mark Nicmanis, Cambridge

Bring back BR. Great stuff.

James Goddard, London

As most of Wales is served by one franchise change would be easy and London service franchise is renewable within two years.

Nicholas Phillips, Cardiff

In many cases the train fare is more than the cost of fuel for the same journey in the car.

Michael Cryer, Aberfeldy

Bring back BR and the age of the train.

Enid Dalton, County Durham

It was better when we owned it.

Graham Hale, Hemel Hempstead

I’m just a train enthusiast. Give me back British Rail and give the people what they deserve.

Kyle McManus, Lincoln

There are far too many different companies operating the railways. It’s far too complicated.

Sueton Sayers, Wolverhampton

Stop the fares rip-off.

Jason Leyton, London

As a teen, I wanted to work for British Rail as a public service which was environmentally sound. That chance was stolen from me by the Tories.

Amanda Ure, Leicester

No to privatisation.

Henry Sherridan, Doncaster

The divergence in prices and many promotions make booking for rail impossible.

Chris Osborne, Norwich

Privately-owned rail companies need to go. Re-nationalise the railways.

Raymon Narwal, Doncaster

Back to running for people not profit.

K Sayer, Leamington Spa

It’s not just the railways, its also the utility companies as well.

Lynda Callaghan, Liverpool

It costs a fortune to travel and the service is below par.

Tony Lansbury, Maidstone

Why should people who cannot afford to get on a train pay for those who also cannot afford to get on a train? If anything, our rail infrastructure should be non-profit.

Shane Ward, Leyton

People are beginning to wake up at last to the evils of capitalism.

Chris Hindle, Bradford

No more money for this mess they’re making.

Dave Bennett, Llanelli