Privatisation rarely works for the average person. East Coast was doing so well so why did that have to change?

Diana Lauder, Wakefield

Many of the private rail companies are foreign national rail networks, so it would better be one British Rail.

Richard Waltereit, Whitley Bay

Not necessarily British Rail but we need a less fragmented railway.

Danny Read, Goole

I believe that it is very important to have a unified, not-for-profit railway sytem to provide travel at reasonable cost..

Derek Bibb, Glasgow

Take it out of the hands of profiteers.

John Perkins, London

Bring back British Rail or I have to put up with a pathetic service.

Scott Free, Saltaire

Bring back one system.

Helen Edwards, Stafford

If railways were nationalised, we could pay people to be station staff instead of paying them to be out of work.

Janet Goodall, Harwich

Shameful actions by respective governments have badly served the population as a whole. Labour need to get back to principles and act, before it’s too late. Some chance.

Paddy Costall, London

I think that British Rail should come back. Let’s hope the train fares go down.

Sam Bridges, Derby

I would like to see is a railway system that is managed and run efficiently with good opportunities for commercial growth and employment. Bring back British Rail.

Richard Stone, Canterbury

Return the rail network to public ownership, not shareholders.

Michael Riches, Wymondham

Transport for the people by the people, not for profit. All service industries must be publicly owned and all monies ploughed back into the service.

Mick Knights, Waltham Cross

You just have to look at the money these CEOs of TOCs pay themselves and the countries that the profits go back to just to see that private ownership is not the best.

Tony Armstrong, Doncaster

The public has been conned by the de-nationalisation of rail, water and power. The only people who have benefited from this policy have been the shareholders.

Jean Addison, Corby

All essential services and transport should be brought back into public ownership. There has been a steady decline in all of these services since they were privatised.

Stephen Pearson, Leeds

The railways are for all, not just for those who can most afford them.

David Anderson, Petersfield

This Government should be sacked.

Frances Tham, London

Long Overdue for changing, this nightmare called privatisation.

Christopher Connery, Birmingham

Tony Blair’s Labour government should have re-nationalised the railways as soon as they came to power.

George Moffat, Whitley Bay

Railways should be run for people, not for profit.

Annette Lillig, Edinburgh

I’m too young to have remembered when the railways weren’t privatised but it sounds like a good idea.

Ben M H, Plymouth

I love nationalised trains.

Jeremy Evans, Brighton

Privatisation has been one of the biggest disasters of all time.

Brian Rattray, Aberdeen

Public service not private profit. It’s that simple.

Nigel McAdam, Manchester

To replace highly trained guards with glorified customer service operatives is ridiculous and an insult to rail users.

Mary Price, Worthing

National public transport should be run for the public by the government and not by profit incentivised commercial companies.

Jonathan Ellison, Cheltenham

The public have had to subsidise the railways so why not simply publically own them and then proper public travel services for all instead of profit motive alone

Nicola Hartley, London