How can you run a railway and claim maximum customer service when you are also giving millions of pounds to shareholders who contribute nothing?

Ian Hayward, Basingstoke

Private companies should not be running something as safety-intensive as our railways. Let’s face it, private company owners want to play golf all day.

Robert Turnbull, Kilmarnock

Privatising the railways has failed the passenger and rewarded only the shareholders.

Roger Kay, Crawley

Privatisation has been a failure, destroying the nation’s public transport and placing considerable additional costs on all users.

Peter Earl, Lewes

East Coast livery dull. Bring back GNER livery.

Alasdair Burman, Skipton

The figures speak for themselves..

Robert Cartwright, Alton

East Coast trains, publicly owned, making huge profits for the government. Privatised rail companies are heavily subsidised by government. Why privatise East Coast trains?

Yvonne Bell, Ryton

Why do I pay more for a shorter journey? Ticket from Weybridge to Kew Bridge is cheaper than the shorter journey from Addlestone. I hate the railway companies.

Gavin Jones, Addlestone

Fully publicly-owned, and fully funded.

Steph Jones, East Yorks

Privatisation is failing. Bring back British Rail.

Bobby Bowden, St Helens

The train ticket lottery is madness, and the obvious lack of true competition between companies is hindering rail transport development.

Alice Saville

If Brexit is here to stay, then the railways should be too!

Christopher Waters, Manchester

I hate foreign ownership of our trains.

Lily Wiles, London

Taxpayers subsidise the private rail companies so that shareholders can have dividends.

Charlie Werner, Sandford

Privatisation of our railways has been a complete and utter failure.

Paul Beattie, Corby

What can I say, really?

Steven Gergus, Bolton

On my line I can only take EMT. One price. Competition? With government subsidy now, why not fully nationalised so re-investment rather than profit to shareholders.

Samuel Shoesmith, Wellingborough

British Rail had more flexibility with tickets and better value. It was better all round.

John Richard Jones, Preston

Fares are too expensive under private control. Improve the service by investing money into the network directly and not into scandalous salaries and bonuses.

Pedro Pereira, Milton Keynes

The shocking, politically-driven carve-up of the nation’s railways was a disgrace. It’s time the politicians climbed out of big-business’s pockets and did what is right.

Gordon Johnston, Biggar

People before profit.

Andrea Coppin, Bristol

British Rail was far more profitable and efficient and affordable than the current system. Thus we need it back for the future.

Stephen James Lemon, Portsmouth

This is what happens – greed before customers when things are put into private hands. It’s time gas and electricity were brought back as well.

Noreen Gorse, Manchester

I can remember when British Rail ran things and there were cancellations and late arrivals, but privatisation ruined the service to all but the folk who made a killing from it.

Jimmy McGurk, Livingston

The privatised companies have now had long enough to show us absolutely clearly that the railways would be better publicly owned.

Eva Fox-G

I’m sick and tired of having our state infrastructure (that belongs to all) sold off to the few. We need service not profit and greed.

Stephen Carpenter, London

Labour must commit to bring rail back to public ownership. Stop the madness.

David Speare, Plymouth

Public transport should be in public hands. Our taxes shouldn’t be going to private corporations to make profit for them: they should go towards a better service.

Abby Sullivan, London

I’m a former BR employee at Westbury. Because of privitisation I was made redundant.It was a very sad day.

John Evans, Westbury

Bring back a national rail system. Privatisation hasn’t worked.

Scott Rundle, Oxford