Our railways will never be working for the benefit of commuters as long as they are run by private companies for profit.

Elaine Nudd, Chesterfield

Definitely Bring back British Rail. Trains and customer service were better back then and tickets were affordable.

Andy Cook, East Sussex

Spend the subsidy on routes not shareholders.

Leila Roberts, Ripon

Rail for the people. not for rich to profit from.

Michael Burn, Sunderland.

Bring back British Rail and sort out this ludicrous mess. Is there anywhere else in the world where ticket prices for the same journey change from day to day?

Les Hughes, Wakefield

Bring back a real rail service instead of the disgraceful, inept, chaotic, money-grabbing, rip-off amalgam of companies who value only short-term profit.

Martin Cooper, London

Isn’t it obvious?

Emma Robbins

Bring back BR. We overpay for a terrible service. Privatisation should never have happened.

Lynda Haydney, St Leonards on Sea

Time for a change.

Greg Sutton, Fleet

It’s simply not possible to deliver effective services to stakeholders whilst maximising profits for shareholders. All the evidence available proves this point. BBBR.

Katrina Dorman, Liverpool

The success of the Direct Operation of East Coast shows that taking all rail services back into public control would most likely be more successful than re-franchising.

Peter J Walker, Billingham

It’s a no-brainer.

Philip Mead, London

We have seen the East Coast line can deliver. Stop these shareholders robbing us of the profits we need for our railways.

Richard Oakes, London

After re-nationalisation, at a national affordable price (one can hope?) begin electrical / magnetic renewable infrastructure.

Chris Harris, London

Make fares fair!

Helen Ferguson, Glasgow

British Rail was originally financed by the British taxpayer. It should be owned again by the British taxpayer.

Anthony Hook, Chesterfield

Why is the government subsidising private companies when all their profits go to shareholders and not to improving the service?

Ruby Makepeace, Brighton

I can’t afford to travel further than Birmingham except by car unless I book weeks ahead.

Peter Starns, Church Stretton

There was more efficient running of trains back then and there were proper locomotives.

Jacob Colclough, Stoke-on-Trent

Bring back British Rail and get rid of this joke of a railway we now have.

Paul Smith, Sheffield

Bring it back to the people. You know it makes sense.

Mark Nevitt, Sandbach

Bring Back BR.

Daniel Ward, Sutton

Re-nationalise our assets.

Linda Barker, Leeds

Bring back British Rail.

Clive Pinnock, Maryport

Some rail operators are operating trains that are so over-full they must be breaking H and S regulations. There should be refunds for passengers without seats.

Peter Davis, Leicester

Bring back British Rail.

Zoe Currie, Norwich

Since we are paying billions every year to subsidise fat cat pay and shareholder dividends we might as well own it.

John Maynard, Harrogate

Taxpayers’ money profiting German and French state rail. A total travesty.

Patricia Julie Brandrick, Uttoxeter

I have been looking for a site like this for years. I thought I was a lonely voice, consider all my contacts made aware of your existence.

Jeff Roberts, Rochdale

Only the Tories could have done this, their revenge on the public knowing they’d lose the 1997 election so they got in quick with this. Typical Tories messing things up.

David Bosher, London