Bring back BR, far better than the current inefficient, expensive, profit-focused private shambles.

Colin Noble, Leeds

Rail, NHS, Mail. These are core social services and should not be run for profit. Directly Operated Rail has proved this will work.

Simon Pickles, Enfield

Just do it.

Gordon Reid, Exeter

Nearly every European country has its state-owned railway. We should have the same, run for the people not fat cats taking all the profits.

Michael Dunne, Darlington

People before profit. Fairness and justice for all.

Paul Leeper, Telford

Britain once owned many fabulous things. Now we barely own the air we breath.

Leanne Bennett, Sunderland

East Coast was a joy to travel on and it made a profit. What a ridiculous thing to have to ask for. nationalisation now.

Lewis Denson, Bristol

The people’s railway. Privatisation is a no.

Jeff Gibson, Sheffield

It’s time this fiasco was ended and the country’s backbone run at cost to make us a world leader.

Lee Gibson, Lincoln

Privatisation and competition works when there is actual consumer choice on offer. Why anyone thought this would apply on rail routes beggars belief.

Imran Husain

They were my employer who I loved working for.

Julian Millichap, Bridgwater

I believe in the railways but not in the way they are run for fat controllers and shareholders. It’s a vital utility, unlike the motor car.

Ian Smith, Chippenham

Bring back our rail for all.

Keoni Kailimai, London

I support the idea of bringing back British Rail because it is ridiculous to think it’s cheaper to fly than to take the train. We’ve had enough, Cameron.

Martyn Lyman, Leicester

Profit is king at the moment. Mammon triumphs again.

Jeffrey Moore, Leeds

We used to own the whole network, until it was stolen by the Tories and sold.

Alison Webster, Banwell

I am utterly stunned at the appalling state of our rail network. This needs to be put right. I have stopped using trains and started using planes, which are cheaper.

Keith Graham, Cheltenham

Prices have increased and yet even fewer services are run from Bolton. There is no justification for this.

Sheraz Ahmad, Bolton

It works in Northern Ireland. It works when the public sector has to step in to ‘hold the fort’ in between franchise holders or when they lose interest. Bring back BR.

Huw Thomas, Dorchester

Safety and operation of our rail network should not be in private hands. We need an integrated rail system.

Jim White, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

British Rail was for customers not for shareholders.

Patricia Spence, Reading

Privatisation has taken its toll on the whole railway system in Britain, turning it into a complete mess, not to mention train fares going up year after year.

Jamie Spilsbury, Merseyside

It should be back in public hands.

Constance Lee

Businesses are in it for their shareholders, not for the benefit of the people who use the trains.

Van Tran, Nottingham

The Great Train Robbery – the British privatised rail network.

Katie Goodwin, Tadley

Yes! Re-nationalise the railways and everything else we paid for.

Vivienne E Heatley, London

It’s time to put it back where it belongs.

Andy Black, Edinburgh

For the people.

Kerry Pickett, Brighton

I belong to a walking group of retired people whose organiser suffers because of the disorganisation of the various companies running rail transport in the South-East

Philip Michaelson, London