They should never have been privatised. Complete rip-off now.

Paul Hancock, Ferryhill

GNER was the most efficient service in the country when back in public hands, which says it all. Privately owned means profit before investment.

Michael Barlow, Durham

Please bring back BR.

Gill Boden, Cardiff

A shocking service. I’m sick of sending compensation forms and complaining for late running or cancelled trains. It costs a fortune and isn’t reliable. BBBR.

Steve Brown, Newcastle Upon Tyne

The train service at my local station (Poynton) is getting worse and worse because Virgin wants to keep increasing the frequency of the Manchester-London service.

Mike Nash, Poynton

Privatisation has cherry-picked the best routes and neglected less fortunate ones. We need a proper network again.

Peter Yates, Derby

The shambles of railways in this country is a disgrace. We deserve a railway network we can be proud of and the French model shows that national is the way to go.

Craig Morris, Northampton

The lines destroyed by Beeching must be reinstated, and the entire system ring-fenced from all banking influence and run as a not-for-profit public service.

C Haines, London

British Rail should belong to the British people.

Karen Heaton, Stockton-on-Tees

This is not good for the public, just another rip-off by the government.

Malcolm Hinksman, Luton

Privatised railways are a Victorian concept.

Gerard Moore, London

Please re-nationalise and invest in competent managers.

David Millar, Stoke-on-Trent

It should be run by people for the people not for the rich and greedy.

Leonard Jones, Ellesmere Port

I am tired of being late for work, late getting home, waiting nervously for trains at unmanned stations, and having no toilets or waiting rooms open on a cold night.

Donna Ainsworth, Leatherhead

Private ownership of rail companies puts profit before customers and allows private companies to profit from failure. This is unacceptable and needs to change.

Joshua Harper, Manchester

The railways are far too important to allow private firms to run them into the ground. These companies bring no money or expertise to the industry, yet they get rich.

James Evans, London

Are our trains better or cheaper now? Not at all. The pricing policy is a joke.

Gordon Hay, Sandiacre

Privatisation means fragmentation and the loss of co-ordination and accountability. It also means a profit take from every part of the service leading to higher costs.

A Mathur, Wirksworth

The way things are going with privatisation, there will be no safety left on the railways, with all the job cuts, disasters waiting to happen. I work for them.

Ray Tidd, Southend

The only way forward.

Lucy Bell, Reading

Let us undo the great mistake that New Labour would not, when they had a golden opportunity.

John Carlisle, Sheffield

If our government is serious about the shift from road to rail then now is the opportunity.

Mike Friend

After travelling to many European countries and using their train systems it is easy to see what we must do to fix our horrendous train service in the U.K.

Robert Morris, Uttoxeter

My Father spent 41 yrs on the railway, from cleaner to top link driver, Royal Train et al. He said it would go to pot.

Philip Knight, North Petherton

There has been no evidence that privatising the railways has been in the public interest. The railways are still subsidised and there is no benefit to the rail users.

Philip Elliot, Sheffield

Track, rolling stock, time-tabling, maintenance planning, financing all run by one organisation working for the same purpose. What’s wrong with the common sense of that?

Roger Gowers, Telford

I just love our trains, so save them.

Sue Richmond, Sheffield

The railway is a service, not a business. It enables business, so should be viewed as a means to an end, not run as the end itself.

Andrew Mclean-Reid, Sherfield

If the rail industry is ‘private’ why then do the train operating companies take their profits whilst the taxpayer is still contributing considerably to the rail network.

Stuart Wilkins, Brockenhurst

They should never have been privatised. It is costing the taxpayer far too much and fares are unacceptably high. We are at the mercy of privateers.

Simon Harris, Mansfield