Privatisation has made us realise how good British Railways really were. The East Coast line is well run and makes a profit, bringing in money to the Treasury.

John Norman, Ashford

Around Manchester Piccadilly there are lots of diesel fumes with only a few services using electric trains. If the government fails to re-nationalise our railway, I will.

Jeffrey Wong, Manchester

Higher prices, poorer services, year on year. How long do they think people will be pissed on like this?

Andrew Wale, Hove

How is my station in Zone 4 while the one about half a mile from it – faster into London – is in Zone 6?

John Gilbert, Bromley

No public services like this should benefit shareholders rather than users.

Karen Chambers, Edinburgh

Too expensive and all too crowded.

Margaret White, Cheltenham

I’m too young to remember the railways before privatisation, but I am disgusted with the colossal increases in fares every year. Re-nationalise the railways.

Kade Ramsey, Colchester

How are you supposed to have a flourishing and prosperous civilization if you cannot get anywhere?

Elizabeth Cunningham, Norwich

British Rail appeared to be more reliable and less costly.

Sandra Foster, Rainham

It is insanity not to have a British Rail system that is coherent, coordinated and not about profit. Efficient transport should be part of the infrastructure.

Sue Mills, Leeds

142 Pacers would have been replaced long ago under a nationalised railway system, not cascaded down. The stock in the South of England is so superior to that in the North.

Alan Glover, Hexham

Privatisation is a mess. It’s just ripping off the public and taxpayers.

Christine Sweeney, Durham

Born in privatisation, will live to see the day when British Rail is brought back.

George Everett

Terrible idea when they did it, and even worse now.

Justin Rivett, Taunton.

ScotRail is a joke. See #failrail for details on Facebook. No seats 40% of time, 30 or more minutes delayed or just fully cancelled.

Alan McDonald, Clackmannan

I’m president of Birmingham Trades Union Council. All public transport should be in public hands. People before profit.

Mary Pearson, Birmingham

This isn’t competition, it’s theft. I’m a life long Tory voter, but if Labour fix the utilities they’ll have my vote come the next election.

Mark Beeby, Norwich

Not just rail – all utilities too.

Martyn Lynch, Harrogate

Reduce huge fares and simplify the ticketing system.

Steve Pearce, Leeds

Our railways are the most expensive and the most unreliable in Europe.

Andrew West, Chatham

British Rail was much better than everything that followed.

Roderick Slater, Edinburgh

What the Tories said about privatisation was wrong – better service, lower fares and competition. None of that has happened!

Andy Teed, Devon

It’s a disgrace at present.

Steve Barrett, Nottingham

Get rid of the spivs and shysters from our railway.

Dugald Cameron, Glasgow

Our private rail network is more expensive for users, fares are increasing all the time, it’s expensive for taxpayers, the service is terrible. Bring back British Rail.

Duncan Moore, Glasgow

Vote Green to bring back British Rail.

Jon Matthews, Swanley

For the sake of convenience, and especially for those travellers who have to travel across country, let’s get tickets through one organisation.

Alan Martin, Weston-super-Mare

It’s inescapable logic.

Shirley Jones, Northampton

Abellio Greater Anglia are the worst company. I hope this really proves people are fed up and changes need to happen.

Amy Williams, South Woodham Ferrers