Something wrong with the service if it’s cheaper to fly from Elgin to Manchester than use the train service. It needs change.

Mark Pilkington, Elgin

Privatisation has been a failure, destroying the nation’s public transport and placing considerable additional costs on all users.

Peter Earl, Lewes

Privatisation was a huge mistake. A re-nationalised railway would be much better as long as the government invests the money needed.

David Whalley, Oldham

If foreign state railways can make a profit out of our railways, why can’t our state?

Kay Turberville, Lowestoft

It is so very expensive to go by train in this country compared with Europe and the USA. it is subsidised in those countries and so cheap to travel anywhere.

Anne Wren, Sale

Bring back nationalisation.

David Richardson, Bedlington

I regularly travel on Cross Country. Compared to East Coast, the trains are overcrowded, noisy, a poor service and often blocked toilets. Profit has been put before people.

Peter Hay, Darlington

The railways should be run as a public good, for public benefit, not for profit to shareholders.

Craig Thomas, Manchester

Nationalise the railways for the benefit of us all.

Colin Laidler, Washington

Rail is overpriced and should be nationalised as soon as possible.

Dennis Hopkins, Leeds

It’s nonsense that the railways should be run using the present model – it simply does not work. Re-nationalise now.

Jim West, Derby

Give the amenities back to the people.

Sean Michael Fitzpatrick, Rotherham

People are beginning to wake up at last to the evils of capitalism.

Chris Hindle, Bradford

I yearn for the day when British Rail comes back into public ownership. Only Jeremy Corbyn will pledge this.

Gay Whymark, Warwickshire

Trains for the people.

Heather O’Hara, Blackpool

Public ownership is the way forward.

Michelle Drummond, Newcastle upon Tyne

Things have changed for the worse, and not for the better.

Elizabeth Smith, Whitchurch

The railway industry is costing far more to run privatised than ever it did under British Rail.

Dennis Pocock, Woking

If railways were nationalised, we could pay people to be station staff instead of paying them to be out of work.

Janet Goodall, Harwich

Although it was by no means perfect as BR, it was a whole lot better than now. Employ real railway people at the top too, not business Muppets who don’t understand.

Kaeren Daunt-Jones, Rochester

The privatised system doesn’t work. Nightmare pricing, poor service.

Barbara Hastings, Nottingham

Yes please – a properly joined-up rail network service.

Deirdre Carlisle, Dumfries

A return to the days of a national service run not for profit. If only.

Ben Illis, Brighton

To centralise and make it less about profit is the only way.

Kate Tomes, Maidstone.

We need a cheaper, fairer railway system for all. The social impact of the railways should be priority and more branch lines should be reopened.

Laurence Poole, Clevedon

I’m sick of this.

Jack Thompson, Reading

The time has come to undo much of the havoc wrought be the unlamented Margaret Thatcher.

Rob Lucas, Ross-on-Wye

Our railways are in chaos: expensive tickets seldom guarantee a seat; overcrowded, underinvested and in need of intensive care.

Ian France, Sheffield