I am at a complete loss as to why we have these different companies. People should be encouraged to use public transport, to save the pollution of their own cars.

Glyn Pope, Barry

14 years I served under British Rail, then cast aside under Virgin. They should never have been privatised.

Jacqueline McEvoy, Birmingham

Nationalisation means simplification, for all concerned.

Peter Fairhurst, Gateshead

we need a railway system that serves the people.

Josephine Smoldon, Bridgwater

It’s despicable that the train operating companies collect fat profits from driving the prices up on an essential public service.

Josh Kerry, London

I always complained about the Italian railways (public) but Great Western railway makes me miss it. Greatest case of privatisation failure ever.

Giacomo G, London

Far be it that the operation of the rail network should cease to be a joke. It could at least be a slightly less expensive joke.

Oliver French, Bristol

Cornwall is badly served by current train companies. Slow indirect trains, often no catering facilities, and expensive to get anywhere up-country.

Hilary Roberts, Penzance

Privatisation was and still is a publicly funded rip-off, to defraud the public of money, the very taxes we all pay. Shame on you Con-Dems!

Zack Kahn, London

I am strongly against this sell-off.

Derek Shaw, York

The national railways ought to belong to everyone in the country and not be just for the benefit of the shareholders.

Sue O’Connell, Leigh

The fragmentation of the system caused by privatisation is a disaster and fares are too high because of the need to satisfy shareholders.

Howard Elcock, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Start with the railways, then re-nationalise gas, water and electricity. Hands off the Royal Mail too!

Iain Logan, Liverpool

Everything in the ‘We are the collective’ statement rings true.

Chris Nicoll, Berwick-upon-Tweed

Public transport in public hands.

Paddy Carstairs, Dalkeith

Save the country a fortune, do it now.

William Boyle, Glasgow

Run the railways as a service like the roads, not a cash cow like banking.

Rob Hague, Derby

End the crazy ticket price lottery and bring back direct trains from Shrewsbury to London.

Paul Baskeyfield, Church Stretton

French railways are nationalised and are generally considered better than ours. Why not ours?

Les Leckie, Cheadle

Let’s go back to when the trains were on time and not in the private sector, with all the investors taking all the money out of it.

Alexander Wallace, Sheerness

I am fed up with the cost of travel and the constant excuses for late trains and cancellations. BR needs to come back.

Jan Ashworth, Stoke Poges

Profits are like rust to public services.

Jonathan Ravenhill Lloyd, Hastings

Public transport for the public not cash cows for corporate fat cats.

Olly Perry, Bristol

Take back our railways. They’re ours…

Margaret Kerr, Wirral

Let all future public investment in trains and railways be a retained mutual equity stake, with a six month notice to exit, withdraw public shares and move on if not satisfied.

Kester Ratcliff, Bristol

For the people not private profit.

Elizabeth Moulding, Cramlington

Bringing back British Rail will allow for a better rail network providing better rolling stock, stations and fewer failures, lower fares and less crowding.

Jacob Tyne, Torquay

Stop privatising the railways.

Liz O’Brien, London

Transport for the people.

Ruth Charlton, Ilkley