With privatisation the national interest takes second place to profits and strategic planning is ineffectual. Bring back BR.

Ian Semple, Peterborough

Forget HS2 Project – Invest it in re-opening more useful cross-country branch lines such as Steyning Line.

Graham Leigh, Lancing

BR cost taxpayers about a third of what the privatised railway does now and was cheaper for passengers too. Nationalise franchises when they expire for greater efficiency.

David Sterratt, Edinburgh

Re-nationalisation of railways is an essential campaign to resist government’s intent on breaking up services currently owned by everybody to line the pockets of the few.

Laura Mitchell, Edinburgh

Profits no. Investment yes.

Nicholas Blomstrand, London

The system is a mess. Ticketing practices and pricing make the system very difficult to navigate.

Alan Bennett, Walsall

It was once ours. Profiteers should not get richer by setting extortionate fares and providing a disgraceful service.

Mark Ross, Mansfield

Not just popular with Labour core voters, but it would be popular in commuter land.

Hedley McCarthy, Blaenau Gwent

Private companies messed it up once. Nationalised it had its faults, but this re-privatisation is a disaster. The only investment in our railways is still public.

Jon Carver, Bedford

Enough of the madness. Re-nationalise now.

Mick Green, Totnes

It’s the obvious fix. Lower prices, better service and better benefits for employees as well as the customer. It’s a no-brainer.

Reece Hancock, Brighton

Stockton and Darlington taught us that railways must be fully integrated – track, trains, repairs et al. The current system is expensive lunacy.

Bryan Sadler, Lancaster

The railways belong to all of us and should be in public control.

Chris Whitehead, Bristol

British taxpayers should own British Rail, not French taxpayers or private investors.

Dorothy Granville, Middlesbrough

My dream from when I was in my 20’s was to see Britain by rail — as it had the best railroad system in the World. I hope to still do that some day. Please de-privatise.

Naomi Durkin, Cortlandt Manor, New York

The worst service since the great days of BR Southern Region.

Alan Bettridge, London

Why is it cheaper to travel by car than by train?

Philip Quinton, Aylesbury

Why change when it was flourishing?

Anne Pender, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

What’s happened to the rail, as with everything, is a disgrace. Money before people. Bring back British Rail.

Ilija Jovanovic, Derby

British rail was the best and most reliable railway we ever had in this country. We need our railway back now!

Brandon Nicholls, Manchester

The rail network does not work under privatisation and needs to be taken back into our hands, run for commuters not profiteers.

Dot Walker, Maldon

Basic transport should be a right in this country. Stop the fat cats profiting and support the public.

Robert Sunners, Cockermouth

This is the only way forward before foreign companies buy up all the silver in this country. Keep British Railways British.

John Lock, Olney, Milton Keynes

Should be non profit making Any profit ploughed back into the business.

Marilyn Riches, Portsmouth

Get rid of Southern.

Ethan Storey, Chichester

Rail CEOs get huge bonuses while services get worse.

Gareth Edwards, Bath

Take back our railways. They’re ours…

Margaret Kerr, Wirral

Rail travel is an essential part of daily life for lots of us and I believe that this service should be nationalised and focus on service not profit.

Michelle Bates, Leeds

For the people, not for private profit.

Stewart Moffat, Eccleshall

Shocking company, greedy CEO.

Steve Emsley, Huddersfield