It’s a joke how much the trains cost. In the era of productivity being bigger than ever, the state could afford public transport to be really cheap.

Maciej Krzymieniecki, Barry

The private companies receive a level of subsidy BR could only dream of and deliver an inferior service with higher fares and antiquated rolling stock.

Peter Karch, Nottingham

Cheaper to run a car than go on a train. Yes, you have traffic, but you’re in your own world and not stuck thinking “Why am I paying this much just to get to work?”

Paul Chappell, London

I totally agree. Not because the old BR was brilliant, but because it can be.

Peter Nicholls, Stoke-on-Trent

Just compare rail travel in France or Italy.

Elizabeth Tierney, Nottingham

I occasionally use the railway myself and I’m getting fed up with buying too expensive tickets on buses and trains. It’s about time to bring back a state owned infrastructure.

Ian Neave, Great Yarmouth

For too long a rich minority has controlled key parts of our society. First we will get the trains back then all our other basic utilities.

Antony Woolley

Frequent travellers need decent fares.

Roxana Anniuk, Philadelphia, USA

Just give it back, please.

Maggie Gallimore, Nottingham

Let the people benefit from the railway.

Ronald Cross, Warrington

Keep the profitable East Coast main line in public ownership.

Richard Hull, St Leonards-on-Sea

Privatisation of public transport is not working. Give it back to the public and it can be great. See Germany as a perfect example of great transportation.

Philip Spencer, Manchester

We have fallen too far behind other nations when it comes to public transport. We tried but failed to improve when we sold off our railways.

Darren Fisher, Hull

We want our public transport service back. We still pay for it in taxes.

Eira Short, Rochdale

Re-nationalise the railways. Use the profits to keep fares down, invest in infrastructure and pay decent wages.

Adrian Lobb, Glasgow

Ownership of the railways should never have been taken away from the people to line the pockets of state-funded fat cats.

David Merry, Bedford

Make fares fair again.

Sam Roberts, London

The current rail system needs to go.

Amanda Dawes, London

I travel on the trains a lot. I spend as much on rent as I do on trains per month. Why do we spend so much for a greener way to travel? Look at Europe’s train prices.

Juliette Burton, Edinburgh

Where is the evidence that private rail companies work better than public? As with many of these projects, it is driven by political and business leaders’ interests.

Tosh Owen, Leeds

Let’s do this as the British people together. Whoever thought splitting it up was a sensible idea?

Sue Dean, Warwick

For the good of the planet, for the good for us. Transport is a necessity, and not for private profit.

Phillip Quarry, Gloucester

The answer to the failure of privatisation is not more privatisation.

Steven Palmer, Swansea

Southwest Trains are crooks.

Paul Sheppard, London

Crosscountry run a very busy city service with not enough stock. Trains are overcrowded with catering at a minimum. We have to do better than this.

Kenneth Holliday, Stockton-on-Tees

I have lived in Southend we have two rail companies, C2C and Anglia. The price from Southend Central to Fenchurch Street during the week is disgusting.

Jeremy Thomas, Southend-on-Sea

We should re-nationalise not only British Rail but the Post Office, the Electricity and Gas companies and London Transport etc.

Sue Brown, Bishops Stortford

I’m honoured to sign.

Olivia Sykes, Huddersfield

The national rail network should be run for the benefit of the nation, not just for the profit of the few.

Alan Milne, Edinburgh

We have an absolute mess now.

Denise Smith, Exeter