This debacle has been going on for too long, let’s make a change.

A J Allan, East Lothian

It should never have been stolen from us in the first place.

Leon Maurice-Jones, London

It has to be done.

Mike Burgess, Sheffield

East Coast Rail shows how it can be done.

Ian Ferguson, London

Privatisation of BR was one of the biggest mistakes ever. Re-nationalise now.

Martin Percy, Wellingborough

British Rail was far more cost-effective and fairer for commuters than the debacle of a system we have now.

Riz Husain, Harrow

Our rail, our gas, our electricity, our commons, our streets in the hands of profiteers. I hope they shall soon perish.

Sharon Borthwick, London

Affordable, local rail services for everyone!

Nicholas Lyle, Woking / Portsmouth

The railways should never have been privatised. It’s all about looking after shareholders and not passengers. Fares are ridiculously expensive and overcrowding worse.

Mark McCabe, Glasgow

The rail network and companies are failing to meet the needs of their passengers. They should be viewed as public services not for private profit.

Helen Walter, Durham

About time it was put back into the public’s interest.

Kevin Rolph, Launceston

We need a coherent and fair transport system for this country which people can afford to use. Private interests have led to exorbitant fares and a fragmented service.

April Virgoe, Ulceby

We want an integrated and expanding system to increase the coverage to areas that were axed as part of the corrupt Beeching plan.

Alan Hill, Camelford

Yes, a train service should be run for the benefit of all, not for the benefit for the few, heavily supported by public funds anyway.

Ken Oatlley, Corsham

In a truly civilized, wise society, things like railways and our electricity/gas provision, should be run by the people for the people.

John Rochford, Middlewich

An excellent idea. Here’s hoping.

Andrea Chapman, London

Putting a public service in the hands of private companies who put profit before service is never a good idea.

Anthony Kaye, Barnsley

Both the trains and the rail system should be under one management and it is too big for one company to control.

Ron Greenham, Luton

Division of the rail service into smaller providers would always be economically unviable and a waste of resources.

Chris Stevens, Robertsbridge

Why should so many British institutions be in the hands of private companies?

Sheila Taylor, Sheffield

Simply Bring back British Rail and end all these scam companies that are only interested in lining their own pockets.

Mark Foster, London

Let’s stop this private greed and get back on the right tracks. Public transport.

Phillip Corbett, Harwich

Privatisation clearly doesn’t work.

Neil Tattersall, York

It has priced normal earners out of the commuters’ market

Aisling Leyden, Kettering

Re-nationalise or stop all subsidies. If the private sector is so great why do they need public money?

Alan Bremner, Stockport

The current rail service is not good for taxpayers or consumers and was a poor decision made by government.

Claire Wilkinson, Bedale

It’s a no-brainer.

Philip Mead, London

As an ex BR employee I am very aware of how standards of customer service have declined to near extinction in the past 30 years.

Bill Moss, London

State ownership of railways is much more efficient, as shown by the massive improvements all round when some franchises have been briefly state run recently.

John Thompson, London