Better a public than a private monopoly.

Robin Holden, Chipping Norton

Please let us end the fat cats railway.

Brian Blackett, Cramlington

National transport should belong to the nation.

Jeanette Harold, Consett

No HS2 though, please.

Paul Quadros, Nottingham

East Coast has been run very successfully for the last few years under national control. Why change it?

Rex Birchenough, Peterborough

Bring back trains where seats are available in ordinary class and not just for 1st Class passengers. 1st Class carriages are half empty whilst the others stand for miles.

Kathleen Napier, Preston

I agree that we should re-nationalise the railways and make them more affordable.

Hampton Family, Westgate-on-Sea

I am a firm believer in Bring back British Rail – one railway, one train operator, one company.

Simon Pawelko, Llanelli

People not profit.

Rachel Parsons, Leicester

Privatisation has been an absolute disaster. It’s time to run the railways for people, not profits for a few. I am embarrassed when I go abroad and see their railway systems.

Evelyn Welsh, Prestwick

Railways should be for the benefit of everyone not just for shareholders. It isn’t meant to be a private profit-making enterprise.

Meg Clements, Newton Abbot

I note the escalating subsidy and fares post privatisation. It was a bad idea and did not introduce true competition. East Coast is actually paying money to the Treasury.

Ian Gaynor-Kirk, Falkirk

How much improvement in services could have been funded by the wasteful franchise process?

Ray Butler, Manchester

BR should never have been privatised! This was an error by stupid, greedy, ill informed tory politicians.

Dave Robinson, Colwall, Herefordshire

Trains are too expensive and too crowded.

Shirley Cameron, Sheffield

It really should be a national service that is not for private profit.

Natalie Morton, Leeds

Of course we should bring back British Rail. It’s common sense.

David Burn, York

The privatisation experiment has failed. Rail transport is an integrated service essential to the economy and needs public ownership.

Tessa Gordziejko, Hebden Bridge

Some of us are old enough to remember the railways used to run a lot better than they do now, and it was affordable for everyone. We need to take it back.

Rita Stroud, Ipswich

Our rail services are an embarrassment when compared to those of our fellow European nations. We owe it to ourselves to sort it out.

Jack Heywood, Harrogate

Why privatise something which is making a profit and doing the job well?

Brenda Topley, Leeds

Slow, bad service, overcrammed carriages make it worthwhile for my husband and me to live in separate cities and keep our sanity. Nationalise railways and improve system.

Mahsa Avadi, Leeds

Public services not for profit.

Darren Balshaw, Potters Bar

Why should we pay subsidies to these companies in order that they can make a profit?

Roy Whittles, Huddersfield

It was the worst decision ever to privatise railways, just to make money for the few while giving passengers the worst service.

John Dalby, Leigh-on-Sea

British Rail is best!

Paul Thacker, Newport

At least Ronnie Biggs wore a balaclava.

Martin Alcock, Stoke-on-Trent.

Please keep our rail network British and invest.

Toby Starr, Crawley