Either bring back British Rail or the big four railway companies (GWR, LMS, LNER and Southern)

Ben Brackenbury, Exeter

Privately-owned and operated railways do not put the passengers first. Re-nationalise now.

Robert Hicks, Hardwicke

Our station is a disgrace, quite third world, and the trains are slower than they were in British Rail days. Also the cheap rate is almost impossible to use.

Edith Glatter, Hemel Hempstead

We pay extortionate prices to stand like cattle. It makes no sense for a railway to be run for private profit.

Mary Ion, Bromley

Create a rail system that works for the country.

David Briggs, Retford

Privatisation of the railways is far more expensive to run than the unified British Rail ever was.

Kevin Walsh, Bushey

If the government had pumped as much into British Rail as they have into all the private companies, we’d have the best bloody train system in the world.

Danny Pritchard, London

The free market has failed.

Anthony Gaunt, Nottingham

British Rail was never the best railway system in the world but it was a whole world better than the profit scamming bastards who run our regional railways now.

Andrew Thomas, Alfreton

Lets stop pretending the emperor has new clothes – this dog’s breakfast of a railway needs sorting out now.

Ray Grey, Machynlleth

Re-privatisation has been an absolute Tory failure, with only ScotRail and Chiltern Railways doing any good.

Claire Calder, Norfolk

I actually remember British Rail and, although not perfect, it made co-ordinated travel more easy,

Rose Nugent, Darlington

Bring back British Rail.

Phil Hine, Manchester

Give it back.

Robert Taylor, Chorley

Time to ring the changes and scrap the private companies.

Graham Weeden, Bedford

Bring back BR and the age of the train.

Enid Dalton, County Durham

Please bring back BR.

Peter Keayes, Longfield

Too many words.

Lee Miller, Warrington

Carry on fighting. Together we can do it.

Ann Hill, Mansfield

National action now!

Daniel Carr, Birmingham

British Rail was efficient and customer-focused. The current system is a profiteering shambles.

Peter Reynolds, Birmingham

Passengers before profit.

Kara McCormack, Nairn

This current rail system has gone to pot and is very expensive. Bring back BR now.

Graham Potter, Stevenage

People not profit.

Maya Bhogal, London

Severe overcrowding.

Melanie James, Uttoxeter

The privatisation of public services experiment is an unequivocal failure. It’s time to take it all back.

Kim Grais, Leeds

The railways should never have been returned to private ownership. The mess they were in then was the very reason for nationalisation. Will they never consider history?

Enid Khan, Leicester

Bring back British Rail.

George Sanderson, Leicester

The railways are for all, not just for those who can most afford them.

David Anderson, Petersfield

If Mr Miliband tore up his advisers’ scripts and enunciated this as a serious aim for next year he could just win to give this notion real traction.

Martin Egan, Torbay