The franchising system doesn’t work and needs to be nationalised.

Noordad Aziz, Great Harwood

When British Rail had the railways, things were so much better.

Richard Longhurst, Surbiton

I want the integrated functioning system we used to have, at affordable prices and employing porters, line gangs, cleaners etc. – all the jobs there used to be.

Erica Flint, Egremont

Bring back British Rail or I have to put up with a pathetic service.

Scott Free, Saltaire

The London train system desperately needs improving.

Paul Nelson, London

Keep this railway in public ownership. It works for the majority. Keep greedy hands off.

Brian Appleby, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Return our railways to public ownership.

Oliver Steward, Norwich

The rail network needs to be unified, and as the East Coast main line proves, running under public ownership after two private company failures, a profit can be made.

John Seymour, Tadcaster.

We are paying twice for our services – once through fares and the other through taxes. Stop the rip off.

Ernest Williams, Eckington

Privatisation has worsened the service, making profit for the French, German and Dutch states.

Shakeel Goulthorp, Coventry

It is so financially obvious (which is very important to this government) that further comment really is not needed. Wake up Labour Party. We all hacked off on this one.

John Hindhaugh, Gateshead

This should be affordable for everyone and not just the rich.

Aaron Fry, Plymouth

Fingers crossed.

David Massie, Aberdeen

Bring back British Rail.

John Pruvedenti, Somerset

I despise those managers. I want to buy a ticket from a human being.

Mark Estkowski, Manchester

I always thought Labour should re-nationalise all our services as well as BR.

Eunice Wormald, Nuneaton

This would stop us being ripped off by all the different train companies and the profits staying in this country.

Trev Davis, Gloucester

People before profit.

Susan Englefield, London

Fares keep rising, there are fewer trains and the ones that do turn up have shorter coaches which are not keeping up with the demand of more passengers.

Steven Evans

A great rail system was destroyed by privatisation.

Samuel Hawthorne, Ramsgate

Rail privatisation has been a massive con, leaving us with a fractured network and a cabal of companies sucking up public funds for private profit.

Oscar Franklin, Chatham

In our country we are in the middle of a similar fight against the private rail operators.

Christian No

If the railways are publicly owned there is always someone to actually take responsibility, otherwise each privately owned section passes the buck.

Bernie Ward, Torquay

This needs doing.

K Badlan, Ludlow

Privatisation makes no sense. Money from tickets should pay for a better service, not to pay shareholders (and also to subsidise German rail users’ fares.)

Andrew Taylor, Oxford

This always was the most stupid of the privatisations and if Christian Wolmar thinks it ought to be re-unified, that’s good enough for me.

John Longstaff, Knaresborough

I remember when it was affordable to travel by train. It’s far too expensive these days, so I use my car. I’m not paying for the greedy fat cats’ huge salaries and bonuses.

Robert Collis, Chesterfield

Bring back British Rail.

Trevor Griffiths, Crewe

The present system must be the most inefficient in the world and the poorest value for money.

Colin Bland, Nottingham