Return us to the golden age of nationalised railways.

Marcus Podilchuk, Totnes

Transport, like healthcare and education, is something all our people require to succeed in life. Privatisation has disadvantaged certain regions for too long now.

Courtenay Turner

The railway represents a significant national asset which should be treasured, not milked for maximum profit.

Martyn Dormer, Bath

A privatised rail service has been proven to be unsafe and uneconomic.

Catriona McIntosh, Bedford

It should be a public service not a gravy train.

Helene Hart, Camberley

I want to stop my taxes going into the pockets of the already wealthy parasites.

Graham Wilkinson, Beverley

I’ve just had the worst train journey ever travelling from Birmingham to Wakefield. It took just under 3 hours, making an average speed of 34 mph.

Lynda Pickersgill, Barnsley

Anything’s better than this!

Paul Hampson, Carlisle

This privatisation experiment has failed. The East Coast Line ran at a vast profit when in government hands but not when previously run privately. It’s time for British Rail.

Richard King, Bristol

Everybody, and the environment, benefits from an affordable, dependable and comprehensive public transport system. It should not be run for private profit.

Ian Fraser, Harrogate

By the people for the people.

Pat Crawford, Helensburgh

Private companies succeed by putting profits first. That’s what capitalism is all about. Nationalised companies can put the public benefit first.

James Craig-Gray, London

This country can no longer afford a privatised rail service.

Nathan Lawrence, Redhill

Other countries’ nationalised railways are now running chunks of ours. This is madness. Re-nationalise BR now. There could not be a better opportunity.

R Ramsay, Dundee

We pay higher fares and the taxpayer pays higher subsidies than it cost to run British Rail. All essential infrastructure should be owned and managed by the British Government.

David Saitch, Cheltenham

I don’t understand that when Network Rail do repair work, they have to compensate private train operating companies. If it was state owned, think of the saving.

William Nealon, Rugby

Enough is Enough. Stop robbing people and making their lives a misery. All everyone wants is to be able to get to their job at an affordable cost.

Dympna Child, Ware

Better rail travel is integral to economic growth and reducing the impact on the environment. Only publicly owned, publicly run will achieve this, not a profit-led company.

Simon Barlow, Cheltenham

What would BR look like now if all the money wasted in privatisation had been invested in BR.

Peter Fisher, York

British is best.

Ann Barnes, York

Please bring it back. Ticket prices are way too high and over-crowded trains. More rolling stock is needed.

Darren Stracey

A good idea. East Coast main line has been better in public ownership.

Roger Kojan, Leeds

It is high time to end the farce of pretending that rail privatisation has offered any improvements. It has been an expensive, dogma-driven, organisational shambles.

Raymond Clarke, Abergavenny

Set train fares at pence per mile. National railcard will bring a third off the price of the journey.

Andrew Wetherall, Ashford, Middlesex

It should all be about the service, not the shareholders.

Geoffrey Wootten, Ipswich

Hopefully we will have a nationalised railway company in an independent Scotland.

Catherine Wilson, Campbeltown

Our taxes are used to keep the shareholders happy.

Alun Llewelyn, London

I live a 50 minute train ride from London. I will never work there. Could never afford the season ticket.

Ben Hall, Haywards Heath

Privatisation, fragmentation, subcontracting, internal markets, franchising, managers, managers, managers, jobs for the boys… Rip-off Britain!

James Woodman

Re-nationalise now. Public ownership is the only way.

Martin Curtis, St Ives