Privatisation doesn’t work on all routes – Virgin is OK but Northern is an example of appalling service, crammed in like cattle, dirty old rolling stock and what about H and S?

David Moy, Bolton

I am a Londoner, and one of the reasons why I left for the South Coast was because of the disgrace that is public transport. I support re-nationalisation fully.

Michael Apostolou, Worthing

The franchise system is a joke. BBBR.

Mark Pascoe, London

It was lunacy to privatise in the first place. Railways should be for the public good – for people not profit.

Steve Black, Southampton

We should re-nationalise as it is cheaper than state subsidy of private companies who, with a profit motive, will fail the people in providing a good service.

Steven Gibbons, Folkestone

Bring back British Rail.

Francis Derek Boyle, Manchester

if ran for a bit of profit you’d get more out of it than now when every fucker tax dodges stupid pricks come back to reality

Michael Hancock, Lincoln

The railway is now out of control. Private companies, individuals and the DfT are playing games with shareholders.

Pauline Stephens

This government appears to want to privatise anything that moves. Public transport should be in public hands where it serves the people not the profiteers.

Arthur Bond, Frome

Please reverse the privatisation of the railways.

John & Beatrice Rogers, Leeds

It just makes sense.

Glyn Littlewood, Barnsley

Bring back our low fare railways God Save British Rail.

Norman Clegg, Blackpool

Major gave our railways away, so how about having it given back to us on the same basis. In fact the people of Britain did not consent in the first place.

Robert Montague, Langley Mill

I hate the idea ‘Public Bad, Private Good’ still persists. Directly Operated Rail are paying money back into the system not taking it out like the private companies.

Chris Warren, Bath

Privatisation has been a complete disaster and has definitely not brought benefits for rail users.

Angela Sansam, Harrogate

We are the owners of East Coast rail line and that is cost effective. Why should we give away our heritage to big businesses who are only interested in their profit?

Alan Milne, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Twenty years of private incompetence. It’s time to re-nationalise.

David Bonner, Harrow

Please bring back British Rail and get rid of South Eastern Trains.

Steve Jackson, Welling

We need a joined-up service and joined-up thinking.

Andi Fox, Doncaster

Trains for transport not profit.

Leslie Dalton, Weston-super-Mare

Bring back our railway system.

Jack Painter, Telford

The success of East Coast where private companies failed makes the case for bringing back British Rail.

Eileen Gibbon, Sheffield

Britain deserves better than the total shambles that privatisation was always going to be. Money for fat cats doesn’t provide a decent railway.

Kevin Gaylard, New Milton

Half empty first class seats, standing only on certain routes with above inflation ticket prices. Compare East Coast financial figures with franchises. No contest.

Danny Kearney, London

A ludicrously over-priced and over-complicated railway system.

Susan Crawford, Newcastle-upon-Tyne

Please re-nationalise the railways.

David Palmer, Newbury

It is August 29th and the cheapest available ticket for travel between London and Morpeth on Sunday 13th November is £80. That’s utter robbery.

Brian Martin, Morpeth

We’re now suffering from all the privatisation programmes from the 80s Tory era. Bring back nationalisation of them all. Rail, oil, energy companies. And the rest.

Ann Love, Pembrokeshire

I’m sick of bogus fares and little tricks like split tickets. We want a fair fare system..

Peter Hubberstey, Preston