Because what we have at the moment is not fit for purpose and all it achieves is the fattening of corporate wallets.

Gavin McBride, Edinburgh

I am totally dissatisfied by the way that Northern Rail is run. “Couldn’t care less” seems to be their almost universal attitude at all levels.

Chris Youhill, Leeds

Sell off a public service, pay the owners to keep it running, let them have bonuses from the till while not carrying out maintenance work for years, Oh, and up the fares.

Tula Maxted, Swanley

By improving the current rail system, fewer people will be tempted to use cars for longer journeys which would make the environment more sustainable.

Mike Stevens, Lancaster

High fares, and taxpayers subsidies going in to the pockets of the few. Standardised BR Rolling stock was much more cost-effective than all the foreign trains of today.

David Fuller, Luton

Privatisation has failed. Bring BR back into public ownership.

Tim Hill, Southampton

It was a bad idea to privatise it and now re-nationalisation is the only way to bring sense and efficiency to train travel.

Netti South, Sheffield

A reliable, affordable, state-run railway would benefit the whole country.

Sarah Hurley, Bristol

Privatisation has taken its toll on the whole railway system in Britain, turning it into a complete mess, not to mention train fares going up year after year.

Jamie Spilsbury, Merseyside

Southern Rail is a disgrace, negatively impacting the economy, businesses and peoples health and lives.

M Atkins, Chichester

Putting a public service in the hands of private companies who put profit before service is never a good idea.

Anthony Kaye, Barnsley

Imagine what sort of railway we could have had if British Rail had been given half the money trousered by the privatised rail fat cats!

Joginder Singh

Where I live, the cost of a railcard to send a child to school costs a family £600+ a year. No wonder the kids bunk the trains.

Mimi O’Halloran, Deal

Thirteen years of increased prices and increased delays with decreased services. Surely this cannot be justified.

Justin Glover, Cardiff

Get rid of the spivs and shysters from our railway.

Dugald Cameron, Glasgow

Privatisation hasn’t worked and the debt is even bigger than British Rail ever had.

Darren Rafferty, Sheffield

Bring it back where it belongs. To us.

Darrel Watson, London

British Rail should never have been split and sold.

Gwen Daly, Reading

The way the railways are run is not run for the public and the staff, it’s for profit. Safety and public no longer matter. Bring back British Rail.

Carol Wood, Coulsdon

I’m deeply saddened that East Coast has disappeared – such a regressive step.

Lynda Bowen, Tealby

Please, for the sake of everyone bring back British Rail.

Malcolm Cobden, Worthing

Under the current system, no-one is accountable for the many flaws with the train system, which include high fares and overcrowding. This needs to end.

Nick Pike, Warrington

We subsidise rail firms with our taxes, pay way over the top for season tickets from our pre-taxed wages and get an awful service. Profits go to shareholders.

Nik Dadson, Royston

Give the amenities back to the people.

Sean Michael Fitzpatrick, Rotherham

Passenger train operation should be for the benefit of travellers – not shareholders. And a unified InterCity could offer seamless integrated long-distance services again.

Mike Machin, Southampton

And then we can re-nationalise energy and water.

Carmen Edwards, Wrexham

The new timetables are terrible and on top of this there are frequent cancellations and short trains resulting in overcrowding.

Liam Murphy, London

In recent years we have seen spiralling costs, deteriorating services and vast amounts of public money used to subsidise the rail companies. This experiment has failed.

Federico Moscogiuri, Hertford

Take out profit and allow rail staff to co-operate with one another to move people and freight.

Guy Hodgson, Warwick

21st century and our transport system is a shambles. There’s a lesson here – if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Definitely don’t sell it.

Victoria Maclean, Telford